Whom I serve from my forefathers with a pure conscience. That is, have always served and worshipped the one true God, as my forefathers had done, which was true, even when he persecuted the Christians; though this he did not with a pure conscience, but with a false mistaken zeal; and his ignorance could not excuse him, after he might have known Christ. (Witham)
Wednesday of the 9th week in Ordinary Time
First Reading — 2 Timothy 1:1-3, 6-12
1Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ, by the will of God, according to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus:2To Timothy, my dearly beloved son. Grace, mercy and peace, from God the Father and from Christ Jesus our Lord.3I give thanks to God, whom I serve from my forefathers, with a pure conscience, that without ceasing I have a remembrance of thee in my prayers, night and day.6For which cause I admonish thee that thou stir up the grace of God which is in thee by the imposition of my hands.7For God hath not given us the spirit of fear: but of power and of love and of sobriety.8Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but labour with the gospel, according to the power of God.9Who hath delivered us and called us by his holy calling, not according to our own works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the times of the world:10But is now made manifest by the illumination of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath destroyed death and hath brought to light life and incorruption by the gospel.11Wherein I am appointed a preacher and an apostle and teacher of the Gentiles.12For which cause, I also suffer these things: but I am not ashamed. For I know whom I have believed and I am certain that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him, against that day.
1Paul, an Apostle of Jesus Christ through the will of God, in accord with the promise of the life which is in Christ Jesus,2to Timothy, most beloved son. Grace, mercy, peace, from God the Father and from Christ Jesus our Lord.3I give thanks to God, whom I serve, as my forefathers did, with a pure conscience. For without ceasing I hold the remembrance of you in my prayers, night and day,6Because of this, I admonish you to revive the grace of God, which is in you by the imposition of my hands.7For God has not given us a spirit of fear, but of virtue, and of love, and of self-restraint.8And so, do not be ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me, his prisoner. Instead, collaborate with the Gospel in accord with the virtue of God,9who has freed us and has called us to his holy vocation, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given to us in Christ Jesus, before the ages of time.10And this has now been made manifest by the illumination of our Savior Jesus Christ, who certainly has destroyed death, and who has also illuminated life and incorruption through the Gospel.11Of this Gospel, I have been appointed a preacher, and an Apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles.12For this reason, I also suffer these things. But I am not confounded. For I know in whom I have believed, and I am certain that he has the power to preserve what was entrusted to me, unto that day.
1Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, according to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus,2To Timothy, my dearly beloved son: Grace, mercy, and peace, from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Lord.3I thank God, whom I serve from my forefathers with pure conscience, that without ceasing I have remembrance of thee in my prayers night and day;6Wherefore I put thee in remembrance that thou stir up the gift of God, which is in thee by the putting on of my hands.7For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind.8Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but be thou partaker of the afflictions of the gospel according to the power of God;9Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began,10But is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel:11Whereunto I am appointed a preacher, and an apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles.12For the which cause I also suffer these things: nevertheless I am not ashamed: for I know whom I have believed, and am persuaded that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him against that day.
1Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ, by the will of God, according to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus:2To Timothy, my dearly beloved son. Grace, mercy and peace, from God the Father and from Christ Jesus our Lord.3I give thanks to God, whom I serve from my forefathers, with a pure conscience, that without ceasing I have a remembrance of thee in my prayers, night and day.6For which cause I admonish thee that thou stir up the grace of God which is in thee by the imposition of my hands.7For God hath not given us the spirit of fear: but of power and of love and of sobriety.8Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but labour with the gospel, according to the power of God.9Who hath delivered us and called us by his holy calling, not according to our own works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the times of the world:10But is now made manifest by the illumination of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath destroyed death and hath brought to light life and incorruption by the gospel.11Wherein I am appointed a preacher and an apostle and teacher of the Gentiles.12For which cause, I also suffer these things: but I am not ashamed. For I know whom I have believed and I am certain that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him, against that day.
1Paul, an Apostle of Jesus Christ through the will of God, in accord with the promise of the life which is in Christ Jesus,2to Timothy, most beloved son. Grace, mercy, peace, from God the Father and from Christ Jesus our Lord.3I give thanks to God, whom I serve, as my forefathers did, with a pure conscience. For without ceasing I hold the remembrance of you in my prayers, night and day,6Because of this, I admonish you to revive the grace of God, which is in you by the imposition of my hands.7For God has not given us a spirit of fear, but of virtue, and of love, and of self-restraint.8And so, do not be ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me, his prisoner. Instead, collaborate with the Gospel in accord with the virtue of God,9who has freed us and has called us to his holy vocation, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given to us in Christ Jesus, before the ages of time.10And this has now been made manifest by the illumination of our Savior Jesus Christ, who certainly has destroyed death, and who has also illuminated life and incorruption through the Gospel.11Of this Gospel, I have been appointed a preacher, and an Apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles.12For this reason, I also suffer these things. But I am not confounded. For I know in whom I have believed, and I am certain that he has the power to preserve what was entrusted to me, unto that day.
1Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, according to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus,2To Timothy, my dearly beloved son: Grace, mercy, and peace, from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Lord.3I thank God, whom I serve from my forefathers with pure conscience, that without ceasing I have remembrance of thee in my prayers night and day;6Wherefore I put thee in remembrance that thou stir up the gift of God, which is in thee by the putting on of my hands.7For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind.8Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but be thou partaker of the afflictions of the gospel according to the power of God;9Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began,10But is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel:11Whereunto I am appointed a preacher, and an apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles.12For the which cause I also suffer these things: nevertheless I am not ashamed: for I know whom I have believed, and am persuaded that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him against that day.
Responsorial Psalm — Psalm 123:1b-2ab, 2
1To thee have I lifted up my eyes, who dwellest in heaven.2Behold as the eyes of servants are on the hands of their masters, As the eyes of the handmaid are on the hands of her mistress: so are our eyes unto the Lord our God, until he have mercy on us.
1A Canticle in steps. I have lifted up my eyes to you, who dwells in the heavens.2Behold, as the eyes of the servants are on the hands of their masters, as the eyes of the handmaid are on the hands of her mistress, so our eyes are upon the Lord our God, until he may be merciful to us.
1Unto thee lift I up mine eyes, O thou that dwellest in the heavens.2Behold, as the eyes of servants look unto the hand of their masters, and as the eyes of a maiden unto the hand of her mistress; so our eyes wait upon the Lord our God, until that he have mercy upon us.
1To thee have I lifted up my eyes, who dwellest in heaven.2Behold as the eyes of servants are on the hands of their masters, As the eyes of the handmaid are on the hands of her mistress: so are our eyes unto the Lord our God, until he have mercy on us.
1A Canticle in steps. I have lifted up my eyes to you, who dwells in the heavens.2Behold, as the eyes of the servants are on the hands of their masters, as the eyes of the handmaid are on the hands of her mistress, so our eyes are upon the Lord our God, until he may be merciful to us.
1Unto thee lift I up mine eyes, O thou that dwellest in the heavens.2Behold, as the eyes of servants look unto the hand of their masters, and as the eyes of a maiden unto the hand of her mistress; so our eyes wait upon the Lord our God, until that he have mercy upon us.
The psalm slips from singular to plural in two verses: to thee have I lifted up my eyes (v. 1), then so are our eyes unto the Lord our God (v. 2). Augustine makes the shift the key to the whole. It does not say "unto Thee have we lift up our eyes," he observes, but "mine" — which is not individualism but its reverse: "let each of you be this man, for when each of you saith this, since ye are all one in Christ, one man saith this." The other oddity is the pair of household figures. Calmet reads the servant's fixed gaze practically: he is watching his master's hands expecting liberty, "or rather food," or else standing ready to run at the first sign, and Calmet finds the same attentiveness in Homer, where Menelaus keeps his eyes on Agamemnon. The Haydock note closes with a line of Terence to match it — "Take care not to turn thine eyes away from mine." Who wrote it is less certain than what it depicts: the Hebrew adds "of David" and the Syriac agrees, though Calmet thinks Zorobabel and his companions might have recited it at the return, and that it suits captives groaning under oppression — or, as Berthier reports from Augustine, every Christian, who must live in expectation of a better country.
That expectation is what Augustine hears in the psalm's title as a Song of Degrees, and he presses the obvious objection. We sing a song of ascent and see no ladder; the interval between heaven and earth is enormous. "We ascend unto heaven, if we think of God, who hath made ascending steps in the heart" — to ascend is simply to advance toward God, as to fail is to fall without descending anywhere. And the ascent has one characteristic danger: "if while he profiteth he become proud, in ascending he again falleth," which is exactly why the psalm's first act is to lift the eyes off oneself and onto another. Augustine then refuses to let heaven be the sky. If the firmament we see were God's dwelling, that dwelling would pass away, since heaven and earth pass away; and where did God dwell before he made either? The heaven of the psalm is "all holy souls, all righteous souls" — the Apostles were heaven, though on earth in the flesh. The distinction he draws next is precise: you live in a house, and if the house is taken away you fall; God so dwells in the saints "that if He should Himself depart, they fall." The tenant here holds up the building.
On v. 2 Augustine notices what the doubled simile commits us to: "We are both servants, and a handmaiden: He is both our Master and our Mistress." That God should be Mistress is strange only until one remembers he is the Power and the Wisdom of God, and that the maid is the Church — betrothed, not yet married, holding as pledge the blood of the Spouse, and told, unlike other betrothed women, that she may love without apprehension, since no one else could be preferred to the one she awaits. Which sets the terms for the last word of the psalm. Worthington gives the plain sense — as servants and handmaids are attentive and hope to receive sustenance, so we ought to pray with all earnestness for what is necessary, since "all must come from Him." But until he have mercy on us is where the psalm is misread, as though the looking were a means to an end that could stop once the hand moved. Berthier corrects it: read "waiting for his having mercy on us," and understand that "we shall not cease to look up to Him afterwards." The servant does not glance at the hand; he watches it, before the mercy and after.
Gospel — Mark 12:18-27
18And there came to him the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection. And they asked him, saying:19Master, Moses wrote unto us that if any man's brother die and leave his wife behind him and leave no children, his brother should take his wife and raise up seed to his brother.20Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife and died leaving no issue.21And the second took her and died: and neither did he leave any issue. And the third in like manner.22And the seven all took her in like manner and did not leave issue. Last of all the woman also died.23In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise again, whose wife shall she be of them? For the seven had her to wife.24And Jesus answering, saith to them: Do ye not therefore err, because you know not the scriptures nor the power of God?25For when they shall rise again from the dead, they shall neither marry, nor be married, but are as the angels in heaven.26And as concerning the dead that they rise again have you not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spoke to him, saying: I am the God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob?27He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. You therefore do greatly err.
18And the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection, approached him. And they questioned him, saying:19“Teacher, Moses wrote for us that if any man’s brother will have died and left behind a wife, and not have left behind sons, his brother should take his wife to himself and should raise up offspring for his brother.20So then, there were seven brothers. And the first took a wife, and he died without leaving behind offspring.21And the second took her, and he died. And neither did he leave behind offspring. And the third acted similarly.22And in like manner, each of the seven received her and did not leave behind offspring. Last of all, the woman also died.23Therefore, in the resurrection, when they will rise again, to which of them will she be a wife? For each of the seven had her as wife.”24And Jesus responded by saying to them: “But have you not gone astray, by knowing neither the scriptures, nor the power of God?25For when they will be resurrected from the dead, they shall neither marry, nor be given in marriage, but they are like the Angels in heaven.26But concerning the dead who rise again, have you not read in the book of Moses, how God spoke to him from the bush, saying: ‘I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?’27He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. Therefore, you have gone far astray.”
18Then come unto him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection; and they asked him, saying,19Master, Moses wrote unto us, If a man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.20Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife, and dying left no seed.21And the second took her, and died, neither left he any seed: and the third likewise.22And the seven had her, and left no seed: last of all the woman died also.23In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.24And Jesus answering said unto them, Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures, neither the power of God?25For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven.26And as touching the dead, that they rise: have ye not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spake unto him, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?27He is not the God of the dead, but the God of the living: ye therefore do greatly err.
18And there came to him the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection. And they asked him, saying:19Master, Moses wrote unto us that if any man's brother die and leave his wife behind him and leave no children, his brother should take his wife and raise up seed to his brother.20Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife and died leaving no issue.21And the second took her and died: and neither did he leave any issue. And the third in like manner.22And the seven all took her in like manner and did not leave issue. Last of all the woman also died.23In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise again, whose wife shall she be of them? For the seven had her to wife.24And Jesus answering, saith to them: Do ye not therefore err, because you know not the scriptures nor the power of God?25For when they shall rise again from the dead, they shall neither marry, nor be married, but are as the angels in heaven.26And as concerning the dead that they rise again have you not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spoke to him, saying: I am the God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob?27He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. You therefore do greatly err.
18And the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection, approached him. And they questioned him, saying:19“Teacher, Moses wrote for us that if any man’s brother will have died and left behind a wife, and not have left behind sons, his brother should take his wife to himself and should raise up offspring for his brother.20So then, there were seven brothers. And the first took a wife, and he died without leaving behind offspring.21And the second took her, and he died. And neither did he leave behind offspring. And the third acted similarly.22And in like manner, each of the seven received her and did not leave behind offspring. Last of all, the woman also died.23Therefore, in the resurrection, when they will rise again, to which of them will she be a wife? For each of the seven had her as wife.”24And Jesus responded by saying to them: “But have you not gone astray, by knowing neither the scriptures, nor the power of God?25For when they will be resurrected from the dead, they shall neither marry, nor be given in marriage, but they are like the Angels in heaven.26But concerning the dead who rise again, have you not read in the book of Moses, how God spoke to him from the bush, saying: ‘I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?’27He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. Therefore, you have gone far astray.”
18Then come unto him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection; and they asked him, saying,19Master, Moses wrote unto us, If a man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.20Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife, and dying left no seed.21And the second took her, and died, neither left he any seed: and the third likewise.22And the seven had her, and left no seed: last of all the woman died also.23In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.24And Jesus answering said unto them, Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures, neither the power of God?25For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven.26And as touching the dead, that they rise: have ye not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spake unto him, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?27He is not the God of the dead, but the God of the living: ye therefore do greatly err.
The whole argument at the end turns on a tense. God tells Moses from the bush I am the God of Abraham — and the catena stops there: "He did not say, I have been, but I am, as if they had been present." Everything the Sadducees assume is undone by a present-tense verb spoken centuries after the patriarchs' burial, which is why Jesus treats the doctrine as something they should have read, not something now revealed. A second detail is easy to lose in translation. When v. 25 says the risen shall neither marry, nor be married, Bede warns that "the Latin custom does not answer to the Greek idiom": the two verbs are not two different denials but the proper words for the two sides of a wedding, "marry" said of men and "given in marriage" of women. And the seven brothers may not be a fiction. Theophylact treats it as a tale craftily proposed "to make men draw back from belief in the resurrection"; Bede grants it was framed to prove the madness of those who assert the resurrection of the body, but adds that "such a thing however might really have happened at some time or other among them."
Theophylact takes the two charges of v. 24 as two distinct errors. Not knowing the Scriptures, the Sadducees imagine the resurrection as a restoration of bodies exactly as they now are, with the appetites and dependencies that go with them — "but it shall not be so." Not knowing the power of God, they stick on a mechanical difficulty: how can scattered limbs be gathered and rejoined to the soul? — which "in respect to the Divine power is as nothing." The positive account follows. Marriage exists now "on account of our decay, that we may be carried on by succession of our race, and not fail"; where there is no more decay there is nothing for succession to repair, and so marriage ceases — not abolished as an evil but left without work to do. Pseudo-Jerome puts it as a series of absences: there "no man dies, no one is born, no infant is there, no old men." The exposition meets the obvious objection — that God might have spoken only of Abraham's soul — by answering that the name Abraham implies both soul and body. Bede reaches it by the longer road: prove first that the soul survived, since God could not be the God of those who did not exist at all, and the resurrection of the body follows as a consequence, "since it had done good and evil with the soul." Pseudo-Jerome hears more in the wording than the argument requires: the threefold naming implies the Trinity, the single He is not the God of the dead the one substance.
The Sadducean error survives, having changed sides. It is now common to picture the life to come as this life continued and then reject the picture as childish — a manoeuvre Jesus refuses, since the objection stands only against the resurrection the objector invented. The Bible de Vence puts the alternative plainly: those who die in the eyes of the world, never to return to it, do not therefore die in the eyes of God, to live no more. What the passage asks is that the two ignorances be repaired together, because either alone breeds its own error — Scripture without the power of God produces a resurrection too small to want, the power of God without Scripture a hope with no content. Pseudo-Jerome leaves the sharpest image, drawn from the bush Jesus cites: the fire was kindled in it and did not consume its thorns, "so my words set you on fire, but do not burn off your thorns." One can be lit by the argument and keep every thorn.
First Reading · 2 Timothy 1:1-3, 6-12
1Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ, by the will of God, according to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus:2To Timothy, my dearly beloved son. Grace, mercy and peace, from God the Father and from Christ Jesus our Lord.3I give thanks to God, whom I serve from my forefathers, with a pure conscience, that without ceasing I have a remembrance of thee in my prayers, night and day.6For which cause I admonish thee that thou stir up the grace of God which is in thee by the imposition of my hands.7For God hath not given us the spirit of fear: but of power and of love and of sobriety.8Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but labour with the gospel, according to the power of God.9Who hath delivered us and called us by his holy calling, not according to our own works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the times of the world:10But is now made manifest by the illumination of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath destroyed death and hath brought to light life and incorruption by the gospel.11Wherein I am appointed a preacher and an apostle and teacher of the Gentiles.12For which cause, I also suffer these things: but I am not ashamed. For I know whom I have believed and I am certain that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him, against that day.
1Paul, an Apostle of Jesus Christ through the will of God, in accord with the promise of the life which is in Christ Jesus,2to Timothy, most beloved son. Grace, mercy, peace, from God the Father and from Christ Jesus our Lord.3I give thanks to God, whom I serve, as my forefathers did, with a pure conscience. For without ceasing I hold the remembrance of you in my prayers, night and day,6Because of this, I admonish you to revive the grace of God, which is in you by the imposition of my hands.7For God has not given us a spirit of fear, but of virtue, and of love, and of self-restraint.8And so, do not be ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me, his prisoner. Instead, collaborate with the Gospel in accord with the virtue of God,9who has freed us and has called us to his holy vocation, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given to us in Christ Jesus, before the ages of time.10And this has now been made manifest by the illumination of our Savior Jesus Christ, who certainly has destroyed death, and who has also illuminated life and incorruption through the Gospel.11Of this Gospel, I have been appointed a preacher, and an Apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles.12For this reason, I also suffer these things. But I am not confounded. For I know in whom I have believed, and I am certain that he has the power to preserve what was entrusted to me, unto that day.
1Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, according to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus,2To Timothy, my dearly beloved son: Grace, mercy, and peace, from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Lord.3I thank God, whom I serve from my forefathers with pure conscience, that without ceasing I have remembrance of thee in my prayers night and day;6Wherefore I put thee in remembrance that thou stir up the gift of God, which is in thee by the putting on of my hands.7For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind.8Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but be thou partaker of the afflictions of the gospel according to the power of God;9Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began,10But is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel:11Whereunto I am appointed a preacher, and an apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles.12For the which cause I also suffer these things: nevertheless I am not ashamed: for I know whom I have believed, and am persuaded that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him against that day.
Three words in this charge are sharper in the original than the Douay can show, and the Haydock notes flag each one. Stir up the grace of God (v. 6) renders a Greek verb, anazopurein, that the note explains as a metaphor for fire blown up again — quasi sopitum ignem excitare, as if to rouse a fire that has gone drowsy. Grace here is not a stock but an ember. The spirit of fear God has not given (v. 7) is likewise not fear in general: the note prints the word as deilias, timidity, and adds the explicit correction that it is not phobou — what is excluded is "a cowardly fear, and want of courage," not reverence. And labour with the gospel (v. 8) translates sugkakopatheson, glossed mala ferto mecum; Witham allows the Latin's sense of labouring with Paul in preaching, but says that by the Greek it means "be partner with me in suffering." Timothy is being asked to share a prison, not a workload.
Witham is at his most careful on a phrase easy to slide past. Paul thanks the God whom I serve from my forefathers, with a pure conscience (v. 3) — and Witham refuses the flattering reading. Paul had indeed always served the one true God, as his forefathers had, and that was true even while he persecuted Christians; but that persecution he did not do with a pure conscience, "but with a false mistaken zeal," and Witham adds the sentence that closes the escape route: "his ignorance could not excuse him, after he might have known Christ." Sincerity is not the same as a clean conscience, and inculpable ignorance has a terminus. On v. 6 the notes then diverge over what sacrament is in view. Witham takes the imposition of Paul's hands to be Timothy's ordination as bishop; Denis the Carthusian leaves it open between confirmation and orders and draws a larger conclusion from the ambiguity — the verse "seems to shew that the imposition of hands is used in these two sacraments, as the essential matter," the instrumental cause of the grace conferred. Witham's ear for translation shows again at sobriety: he notes that the Protestant versions render sophronismou "a sound mind" here while rendering the same word "sobriety" in Acts xxvi. 25, 1 Timothy ii. 9, and Titus i. 8.
The most contested phrase is the last. That which I have committed unto him is depositum meum, paratheken mou, and Witham reports the common interpretation: what Paul has deposited in God's hands is the treasure of an eternal reward due in some measure to his apostolic labours, which God will repay at the last day. But Chrysostom declines to close the question, saying the deposit may be either what Paul committed to God's trust or what God committed to Paul — and the two readings pull in opposite directions, one making Paul the depositor and God the guarantor, the other making Paul the trustee who must not lose what he holds. The reading refuses to let either alternative become comfortable. If the deposit is Paul's, then the confidence in v. 12 is not self-confidence: I know whom I have believed, not what I have achieved. If it is God's, then the ember of v. 6 is somebody else's fire, lent out, and the cowardice named in v. 7 is not a temperament to be excused but a failure to blow on it.
Responsorial Psalm · Psalm 123:1b-2ab, 2
1To thee have I lifted up my eyes, who dwellest in heaven.2Behold as the eyes of servants are on the hands of their masters, As the eyes of the handmaid are on the hands of her mistress: so are our eyes unto the Lord our God, until he have mercy on us.
1A Canticle in steps. I have lifted up my eyes to you, who dwells in the heavens.2Behold, as the eyes of the servants are on the hands of their masters, as the eyes of the handmaid are on the hands of her mistress, so our eyes are upon the Lord our God, until he may be merciful to us.
1Unto thee lift I up mine eyes, O thou that dwellest in the heavens.2Behold, as the eyes of servants look unto the hand of their masters, and as the eyes of a maiden unto the hand of her mistress; so our eyes wait upon the Lord our God, until that he have mercy upon us.
The psalm slips from singular to plural in two verses: to thee have I lifted up my eyes (v. 1), then so are our eyes unto the Lord our God (v. 2). Augustine makes the shift the key to the whole. It does not say "unto Thee have we lift up our eyes," he observes, but "mine" — which is not individualism but its reverse: "let each of you be this man, for when each of you saith this, since ye are all one in Christ, one man saith this." The other oddity is the pair of household figures. Calmet reads the servant's fixed gaze practically: he is watching his master's hands expecting liberty, "or rather food," or else standing ready to run at the first sign, and Calmet finds the same attentiveness in Homer, where Menelaus keeps his eyes on Agamemnon. The Haydock note closes with a line of Terence to match it — "Take care not to turn thine eyes away from mine." Who wrote it is less certain than what it depicts: the Hebrew adds "of David" and the Syriac agrees, though Calmet thinks Zorobabel and his companions might have recited it at the return, and that it suits captives groaning under oppression — or, as Berthier reports from Augustine, every Christian, who must live in expectation of a better country.
That expectation is what Augustine hears in the psalm's title as a Song of Degrees, and he presses the obvious objection. We sing a song of ascent and see no ladder; the interval between heaven and earth is enormous. "We ascend unto heaven, if we think of God, who hath made ascending steps in the heart" — to ascend is simply to advance toward God, as to fail is to fall without descending anywhere. And the ascent has one characteristic danger: "if while he profiteth he become proud, in ascending he again falleth," which is exactly why the psalm's first act is to lift the eyes off oneself and onto another. Augustine then refuses to let heaven be the sky. If the firmament we see were God's dwelling, that dwelling would pass away, since heaven and earth pass away; and where did God dwell before he made either? The heaven of the psalm is "all holy souls, all righteous souls" — the Apostles were heaven, though on earth in the flesh. The distinction he draws next is precise: you live in a house, and if the house is taken away you fall; God so dwells in the saints "that if He should Himself depart, they fall." The tenant here holds up the building.
On v. 2 Augustine notices what the doubled simile commits us to: "We are both servants, and a handmaiden: He is both our Master and our Mistress." That God should be Mistress is strange only until one remembers he is the Power and the Wisdom of God, and that the maid is the Church — betrothed, not yet married, holding as pledge the blood of the Spouse, and told, unlike other betrothed women, that she may love without apprehension, since no one else could be preferred to the one she awaits. Which sets the terms for the last word of the psalm. Worthington gives the plain sense — as servants and handmaids are attentive and hope to receive sustenance, so we ought to pray with all earnestness for what is necessary, since "all must come from Him." But until he have mercy on us is where the psalm is misread, as though the looking were a means to an end that could stop once the hand moved. Berthier corrects it: read "waiting for his having mercy on us," and understand that "we shall not cease to look up to Him afterwards." The servant does not glance at the hand; he watches it, before the mercy and after.
Gospel · Mark 12:18-27
18And there came to him the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection. And they asked him, saying:19Master, Moses wrote unto us that if any man's brother die and leave his wife behind him and leave no children, his brother should take his wife and raise up seed to his brother.20Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife and died leaving no issue.21And the second took her and died: and neither did he leave any issue. And the third in like manner.22And the seven all took her in like manner and did not leave issue. Last of all the woman also died.23In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise again, whose wife shall she be of them? For the seven had her to wife.24And Jesus answering, saith to them: Do ye not therefore err, because you know not the scriptures nor the power of God?25For when they shall rise again from the dead, they shall neither marry, nor be married, but are as the angels in heaven.26And as concerning the dead that they rise again have you not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spoke to him, saying: I am the God of Abraham and the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob?27He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. You therefore do greatly err.
18And the Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection, approached him. And they questioned him, saying:19“Teacher, Moses wrote for us that if any man’s brother will have died and left behind a wife, and not have left behind sons, his brother should take his wife to himself and should raise up offspring for his brother.20So then, there were seven brothers. And the first took a wife, and he died without leaving behind offspring.21And the second took her, and he died. And neither did he leave behind offspring. And the third acted similarly.22And in like manner, each of the seven received her and did not leave behind offspring. Last of all, the woman also died.23Therefore, in the resurrection, when they will rise again, to which of them will she be a wife? For each of the seven had her as wife.”24And Jesus responded by saying to them: “But have you not gone astray, by knowing neither the scriptures, nor the power of God?25For when they will be resurrected from the dead, they shall neither marry, nor be given in marriage, but they are like the Angels in heaven.26But concerning the dead who rise again, have you not read in the book of Moses, how God spoke to him from the bush, saying: ‘I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?’27He is not the God of the dead, but of the living. Therefore, you have gone far astray.”
18Then come unto him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection; and they asked him, saying,19Master, Moses wrote unto us, If a man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.20Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife, and dying left no seed.21And the second took her, and died, neither left he any seed: and the third likewise.22And the seven had her, and left no seed: last of all the woman died also.23In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.24And Jesus answering said unto them, Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures, neither the power of God?25For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven.26And as touching the dead, that they rise: have ye not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spake unto him, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?27He is not the God of the dead, but the God of the living: ye therefore do greatly err.
The whole argument at the end turns on a tense. God tells Moses from the bush I am the God of Abraham — and the catena stops there: "He did not say, I have been, but I am, as if they had been present." Everything the Sadducees assume is undone by a present-tense verb spoken centuries after the patriarchs' burial, which is why Jesus treats the doctrine as something they should have read, not something now revealed. A second detail is easy to lose in translation. When v. 25 says the risen shall neither marry, nor be married, Bede warns that "the Latin custom does not answer to the Greek idiom": the two verbs are not two different denials but the proper words for the two sides of a wedding, "marry" said of men and "given in marriage" of women. And the seven brothers may not be a fiction. Theophylact treats it as a tale craftily proposed "to make men draw back from belief in the resurrection"; Bede grants it was framed to prove the madness of those who assert the resurrection of the body, but adds that "such a thing however might really have happened at some time or other among them."
Theophylact takes the two charges of v. 24 as two distinct errors. Not knowing the Scriptures, the Sadducees imagine the resurrection as a restoration of bodies exactly as they now are, with the appetites and dependencies that go with them — "but it shall not be so." Not knowing the power of God, they stick on a mechanical difficulty: how can scattered limbs be gathered and rejoined to the soul? — which "in respect to the Divine power is as nothing." The positive account follows. Marriage exists now "on account of our decay, that we may be carried on by succession of our race, and not fail"; where there is no more decay there is nothing for succession to repair, and so marriage ceases — not abolished as an evil but left without work to do. Pseudo-Jerome puts it as a series of absences: there "no man dies, no one is born, no infant is there, no old men." The exposition meets the obvious objection — that God might have spoken only of Abraham's soul — by answering that the name Abraham implies both soul and body. Bede reaches it by the longer road: prove first that the soul survived, since God could not be the God of those who did not exist at all, and the resurrection of the body follows as a consequence, "since it had done good and evil with the soul." Pseudo-Jerome hears more in the wording than the argument requires: the threefold naming implies the Trinity, the single He is not the God of the dead the one substance.
The Sadducean error survives, having changed sides. It is now common to picture the life to come as this life continued and then reject the picture as childish — a manoeuvre Jesus refuses, since the objection stands only against the resurrection the objector invented. The Bible de Vence puts the alternative plainly: those who die in the eyes of the world, never to return to it, do not therefore die in the eyes of God, to live no more. What the passage asks is that the two ignorances be repaired together, because either alone breeds its own error — Scripture without the power of God produces a resurrection too small to want, the power of God without Scripture a hope with no content. Pseudo-Jerome leaves the sharpest image, drawn from the bush Jesus cites: the fire was kindled in it and did not consume its thorns, "so my words set you on fire, but do not burn off your thorns." One can be lit by the argument and keep every thorn.
· sources ·
The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.
First Reading 2 Timothy 1:1-3, 6-12
That thou stir up [2] the grace of God. In the Greek is a metaphor for fire that is blown up again. --- Which is in thee by the imposition of my hands, when thou wast ordained bishop. (Witham) --- The grace, which St. Paul here exhorts Timothy to stir up in him, was the grace he had received by imposition of hands, either in his confirmation, or at receiving the sacrament of orders, being a bishop. This verse seems to shew that the imposition of hands is used in these two sacraments, as the essential matter of the sacraments, being the instrumental cause of the grace therein conferred. (Denis the Carthusian)
Ut resuscites, Greek: anazopurein, quasi sopitum ignem excitare.
Of fear.[3] Of a cowardly fear, and want of courage. --- Of sobriety.[4] Though the Protestants here translate of a sound mind, yet they translate the same Greek word by sobriety in divers other places, as Acts xxvi. 25; 1 Timothy ii. 9 and 15 and chap. iii. 2; Titus i. 8. &c. (Witham)
Timoris, Greek: deilias, timiditatis, it is not Greek: phobou.
Et sobrietatis, Greek: kai sophronismou.
Labour with [5] the gospel. That is, labour with me in preaching, &c. Or by the Greek, be partner with me in suffering. (Witham)
Collabora, Greek: sugkakopatheson. Mala ferto mecum.
By the illumination of our Saviour. That is, by the bright coming and appearing of our Saviour. (Challoner)
I am certain that he (God) is able to keep that which I have committed to him [6] against that day. That is, to the day of judgment. St. Paul here means that which he had committed, or as it were deposited in the hands of God; to wit, the treasure of an eternal reward, due in some measure to St. Paul for his apostolical labours. This treasure, promised to those that live well, the apostle hopes he has placed and deposited in the hands of God, who will reward him, and repay him at the last day. This is the common interpretation. (Witham)
Depositum meum, Greek: paratheken mou. St. John Chrysostom (Greek: log. b. p. 336) says it may be either what St. Paul committed to the trust of God, or what God committed to him: Greek: e o Theos auto parakatetheto, e en autos to theo.
This second epistle Paul wrote to Timothy from Rome, when he was a prisoner there and in danger of his life; this is evident from these words, I am now ready to be offered, and the time of my departure is at hand, ch. iv. 6 . It appears that his removal out of this world, in his own apprehension, was not far off, especially considering the rage and malice of his persecutors; and that he had been brought before the emperor Nero, which he calls his first answer, when no man stood with him, but all men forsook him, ch. iv. 16 . And interpreters agree that this was the last epistle he wrote. Where Timothy now was is not certain. The scope of this epistle somewhat differs from that of the former, not so much relating to his office as an evangelist as to his personal conduct and behaviour.
After the introduction ( ver. 1, 2 ) we have, I. Paul's sincere love to Timothy, ver. 3-5 . II. Divers exhortations given to him, ver. 6-14 . III. He speaks of Phygellus and Hermogenes, with others, and closes with Onesiphorus, ver. 15, to the end .
1 Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, according to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus, 2 To Timothy, my dearly beloved son: Grace, mercy, and peace, from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Lord. 3 I thank God, whom I serve from my forefathers with pure conscience, that without ceasing I have remembrance of thee in my prayers night and day; 4 Greatly desiring to see thee, being mindful of thy tears, that I may be filled with joy; 5 When I call to remembrance the unfeigned faith that is in thee, which dwelt first in thy grandmother Lois, and thy mother Eunice; and I am persuaded that in thee also.
Here is, I. The inscription of the epistle Paul calls himself an apostle by the will of God, merely by the good pleasure of God, and by his grace, which he professes himself unworthy of. According to the promise of life which is in Christ Jesus, or according to the gospel. The gospel is the promise of life in Christ Jesus; life is the end, and Christ the way, John xiv. 6 . The life is put into the promise, and both are sure in Christ Jesus the faithful witness; for all the promises of God in Christ Jesus are yea, and all amen, 2 Cor. i. 20 . He calls Timothy his beloved son. Paul felt the warmest affection for him both because he had been an instrument of his conversion and because as a son with his father he had served with him in the gospel. Observe, 1. Paul was an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God; as he did not receive the gospel of man, nor was taught it, but had it by the revelation of Jesus Christ ( Gal. i. 12 ), so his commission to be an apostle was not by the will of man, but of God: in the former epistle he says it was by the commandment of God our Saviour, and here by the will of God. God called him to be an apostle. 2. We have the promise of life, blessed be God for it: In hope of eternal life, which God, who cannot lie, promised before the world began, Tit. i. 2 . It is a promise to discover the freeness and certainty of it. 3. This, as well as all other promises, is in and through Jesus Christ; they all take their rise from the mercy of God in Christ, and they are sure, so that we may safely depend on them. 4. The grace, mercy, and peace, which even Paul's dearly beloved son Timothy wanted, comes from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Lord; and therefore the one as well as the other is the giver of these blessings, and ought to be applied to for them. 5. The best want these blessings, and they are the best we can ask for our dearly-beloved friends, that they may have grace to help them in the time of need, and mercy to pardon what is amiss, and so may have peace with God the Father and Christ Jesus our Lord.
6 Wherefore I put thee in remembrance that thou stir up the gift of God, which is in thee by the putting on of my hands. 7 For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind. 8 Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but be thou partaker of the afflictions of the gospel according to the power of God; 9 Who hath saved us, and called us with a holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began, 10 But is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel: 11 Whereunto I am appointed a preacher, and an apostle, and a teacher of the Gentiles. 12 For the which cause I also suffer these things: nevertheless I am not ashamed: for I know whom I have believed, and am persuaded that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him against that day. 13 Hold fast the form of sound words, which thou hast heard of me, in faith and love which is in Christ Jesus. 14 That good thing which was committed unto thee keep by the Holy Ghost which dwelleth in us.
Here is an exhortation and excitation of Timothy to his duty ( v. 6 ): I put thee in remembrance. The best men need remembrancers; what we know we should be reminded of. 2 Pet. iii. 1 , I write this, to stir up your pure minds by way of remembrance.
I. He exhorts him to stir up the gift of God that was in him. Stir it up as fire under the embers. It is meant of all the gifts and graces the God had given him, to qualify him for the work of an evangelist, the gifts of the Holy Ghost, the extraordinary gifts that were conferred by the imposition of the apostle's hands. These he must stir up; he must exercise them and so increase them: use gifts and have gifts. To him that hath shall be given, Matt. xxv. 29 . He must take all opportunities to use these gifts, and so stir them up, for that is the best way of increasing them. Whether the gift of God in Timothy was ordinary or extraordinary (though I incline to the latter), he must stir it up, otherwise it would decay. Further, you see that this gift was in him by the putting on of the apostle's hands, which I take to be distinct from his ordination, for that was performed by the hands of the presbytery, 1 Tim. iv. 14 . It is probable that Timothy had the Holy Ghost, in his extraordinary gifts and graces, conferred on him by the laying on of the apostle's hands (for I reckon that none but the apostles had the power of giving the Holy Ghost), and afterwards, being thus richly furnished for the work of the ministry, was ordained by the presbytery. Observe, 1. The great hindrance of usefulness in the increase of our gifts is slavish fear. Paul therefore warns Timothy against this: God hath not given us the spirit of fear, v. 7 . It was through base fear that the evil servant buried his talent, and did not trade with it, Matt. xxv. 25 . Now God hath therefore armed us against the spirit of fear, by often bidding us fear not. "Fear not the face of man; fear not the dangers you may meet with in the way of your duty." God hath delivered us from the spirit of fear, and hath given us the spirit of power, and of love, and of a sound mind. The spirit of power, or of courage and resolution to encounter difficulties and dangers;—the spirit of love to God, which will carry us through the opposition we may meet with, as Jacob made nothing of the hard service he was to endure for Rachel: the spirit of love to God will set us above the fear of man, and all the hurt that a man can do us;—and the spirit of a sound mind, or quietness of mind, a peaceable enjoyment of ourselves, for we are oftentimes discouraged in our way and work by the creatures o our own fancy and imagination, which a sober, solid, thinking mind would obviate, and would easily answer. 2. The spirit God gives to his ministers is not a fearful, but a courageous spirit; it is a spirit of power, for they speak in his name who has all power, both in heaven and earth; and it is a spirit of love, for love to God and the souls of men must inflame ministers in all their service; and it is a spirit of a sound mind, for they speak the words of truth and soberness.
II. He exhorts him to count upon afflictions, and get ready for them: " Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner. Be not thou ashamed of the gospel, of the testimony thou hast borne to it." Observe,
1. The gospel of Christ is what we have none of us reason to be ashamed of. We must not be ashamed of those who are suffering for the gospel of Christ. Timothy must not be ashamed of good old Paul, though he was now in bonds. As he must not himself be afraid of suffering, so he must not be afraid of owning those who were sufferers for the cause of Christ. (1.) The gospel is the testimony of our Lord; in and by this he bears testimony of himself to us, and by professing our adherence to it we bear testimony of him and for him. (2.) Paul was the Lord's prisoner, his prisoner, Eph. iv. 1 . For his sake he was bound with a chain. (3.) We have no reason to be ashamed either of the testimony of our Lord or of his prisoners; if we are ashamed of either now, Christ will be ashamed of us hereafter. " But be thou partaker of the afflictions of the gospel, according to the power of God, that is, expect afflictions for the gospel's sake, prepare for them, count upon them, be willing to take thy lot with the suffering saints in this world. Be partaker of the afflictions of the gospel; " or, as it may be read, Do thou suffer with the gospel; "not only sympathize with those who suffer for it, but be ready to suffer with them and suffer like them." If at any time the gospel be in distress, he who hopes for life and salvation by it will be content to suffer with it. Observe, [1.] Then we are likely to bear afflictions as well, when we fetch strength and power from God to enable us to bear them: Be thou partaker of the afflictions of the gospel, according to the power of God. [2.] All Christians, but especially ministers, must expect afflictions and persecutions for the sake of the gospel. [3.] These shall be proportioned, according to the power of God ( 1 Cor. x. 13 ) resting upon us.
2. Mentioning God and the gospel, he takes notice what great things God has done for us by the gospel, v. 9, 10 . To encourage him to suffer, he urges two considerations:—
(1.) The nature of that gospel which he was called to suffer for, and the glorious and gracious designs and purposes of it. It is usual with Paul, when he mentions Christ, and the gospel of Christ, to digress from his subject, and enlarge upon them; so full was he of that which is all our salvation, and ought to be all our desire. Observe, [1.] The gospel aims at our salvation: He has saved us, and we must not think much to suffer for that which we hope to be saved by. He has begun to save us, and will complete it in due time; for God calls those things that are not (that are not yet completed) as though they were ( Rom. iv. 17 ); therefore he says, who has saved us. [2.] It is designed for our sanctification: And called us with a holy calling, called us to holiness. Christianity is a calling, a holy calling; it is the calling wherewith we are called, the calling to which we are called, to labour in it. Observe, All who shall be saved hereafter are sanctified now. Wherever the call of the gospel is an effectual call, it is found to be a holy call, making those holy who are effectually called. [3.] The origin of it is the free grace and eternal purpose of God in Christ Jesus. If we had merited it, it had been hard to suffer for it; but our salvation by it is of free grace, and not according to our works, and therefore we must not think much to suffer for it. This grace is said to be given us before the world began, that is, in the purpose and designs of God from all eternity; in Christ Jesus, for all the gifts that come from God to sinful man come in and through Christ Jesus. [4.] The gospel is the manifestation of this purpose and grace: By the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who had lain in the bosom of the Father from eternity, and was perfectly apprised of all his gracious purposes. By his appearing this gracious purpose was made manifest to us. Did Jesus Christ suffer for it, and shall we think much to suffer for it? [5.] By the gospel of Christ death is abolished: He has abolished death, not only weakened it, but taken it out of the way, has broken the power of death over us; by taking away sin he has abolished death (for the sting of death is sin, 1 Cor. xv. 56 ), in altering the property of it, and breaking the power of it. Death now of an enemy has become a friend; it is the gate by which we pass out of a troublesome, vexatious, sinful world, into a world of perfect peace and purity; and the power thereof is broken, for death does not triumph over those who believe the gospel, but they triumph over it. O death! where is thy sting? O grave! where is thy victory? 1 Cor. xv. 55 . [6.] He has brought life and immortality to light by the gospel; he has shown us another world more clearly than it was before discovered under any former dispensation, and the happiness of that world, the certain recompence of our obedience by faith: we all with open face, as in a glass, behold the glory of God. He has brought it to light, not only set it before us, but offered it to us, by the gospel. Let us value the gospel more than ever, as it is that whereby life and immortality are brought to light, for herein it has the pre-eminence above all former discoveries; so that it is the gospel of life and immortality, as it discovers them to us, and directs us in the ready way that leads thereto, as well as proposes the most weighty motives to excite our endeavours in seeking after glory, honour, and immortality.
(2.) Consider the example of blessed Paul, v. 11, 12 . He was appointed to preach the gospel, and particularly appointed to teach the Gentiles. He though it a cause worth suffering for, and why should not Timothy think so too? No man needs to be afraid nor ashamed to suffer for the cause of the gospel: I am not ashamed, says Paul, for I know whom I have believed, and am persuaded that he is able to keep that which I have committed unto him against that day. Observe, [1.] Good men often suffer many things for the best cause in the world: For which cause I suffer these things; that is, "for my preaching, and adhering to the gospel." [2.] They need not be ashamed, the cause will bear them out; but those who oppose it shall be clothed with shame. [3.] Those who trust in Christ know whom they have trusted. The apostle speaks with a holy triumph and exultation, as much as to say, "I stand on firm ground. I know I have lodged the great trust in the hands of the best trustee." And am persuaded, &c. What must we commit to Christ? The salvation of our souls, and their preservation to the heavenly kingdom; and what we so commit to him he will keep. There is a day coming when our souls will be enquired after: "Man! Woman! thou hadst a soul committed to thee, what hast thou done with it? To whom it was offered, to God or Satan? How was it employed, in the service of sin or in the service of Christ?" There is a day coming, and it will be a very solemn and awful day, when we must give an account of our stewardship ( Luke xvi. 2 ), give an account of our souls: now, if by an active obedient faith we commit it to Jesus Christ, we may be sure he is able to keep it, and it shall be forthcoming to our comfort in that day.
Place of Writing.-- Paul, in the interval between his first and second imprisonment, after having written First Timothy from Macedonia or Corinth [Birks] (if we are to adopt the opinion that First Timothy was written after his first imprisonment), returned to Ephesus, as he intended, by way of Troas, where he left the books, &c. (mentioned in 2Ti 4:13 ), with Carpus. From Ephesus he went to Crete for a short visit and returned, and then wrote to Titus. Next he went by Miletus to Corinth ( 2Ti 4:20 ), and thence to Nicopolis ( Tit 3:12 ), whence he proceeded to Rome. From his prison there he wrote the Second Epistle to Timothy, shortly before his martyrdom. It is not certain where Timothy was at this time. Some of the internal evidences favor the view of his having been then at Ephesus; thus the salutation of Priscilla and Aquila, who generally resided there ( 2Ti 4:19 ); also that of the household of Onesiphorus, who is stated in 2Ti 1:16-18 to have ministered to Paul at Ephesus, a circumstance implying his residence there. Also, the Hymenæus of 2Ti 2:17 seems to be the same as the Hymenæus at Ephesus ( 1Ti 1:20 ); and probably "Alexander the coppersmith" ( 2Ti 4:14 ) is the same as the Alexander joined with Hymenæus ( 1Ti 1:20 ), and possibly the same as the Alexander put forward by the Jews to clear themselves, not to befriend Paul, at the riot in Ephesus ( Ac 19:33 , 34 ). The difficulty is, on this supposition, how to account for 2Ti 4:12 , 20 : if Timothy was at Ephesus, why did he need to be told that Paul had sent Tychicus to Ephesus? or that Paul had left Trophimus, himself an Ephesian ( Ac 21:29 ), sick at Miletus, which was only thirty miles from Ephesus? However, see on 2Ti 4:12 ; 2Ti 4:20 . Troas lay on the road to Rome from either Ephesus or Pontus, so that 2Ti 4:13 will accord with the theory of either Ephesus or any other place in the northwest of Asia Minor, being Timothy's place of sojourn at the time. Probably, he had the general superintendence of the Pauline churches in Asia Minor, in accordance with his mission combining the office of evangelist, or itinerant missionary, with that of presiding overseer. Ephesus was probably his headquarters.
Time of Writing.-- (1) Paul's first imprisonment, described in Ac 28:17-31 , was much milder than that in which he was when writing Second Timothy. In the former, he had liberty to lodge in his own hired house, and to receive all comers, guarded only by a single soldier; in the latter, he was so closely confined that Onesiphorus with difficulty found him; he was chained, his friends had forsaken him, and he had narrowly escaped sentence of execution from the Roman emperor. Medieval legends represent the Mamertine prison, or Tullianum, as the scene of his incarceration with Peter. But this is irreconcilable with the fact of Onesiphorus, Linus, Pudens, &c., having access to him. He was probably under military custody, as in his former imprisonment, though of a severer kind (2Ti 1:16-18; 2:9; 4:6-8, 16, 17). (2) The visit to Troas ( 2Ti 4:13 ) can hardly have been that mentioned in Ac 20:5-7 , the last before his first imprisonment; for, if it were, the interval between that visit and the first imprisonment would be seven or eight years, a period most unlikely for him to have allowed to pass without sending for his cloak and parchments, when they might have been of service to him in the interim. (3) Paul's leaving Trophimus sick at Miletus ( 2Ti 4:20 ), could not have been on the occasion mentioned in Ac 20:15 ; for, subsequent to that, Trophimus was with Paul in Jerusalem ( Ac 21:29 ). ( 4 ) The words ( 2Ti 4:20 ), "Erastus abode at Corinth," imply that Paul had shortly before been at Corinth, where he left Erastus. But before his first imprisonment, Paul had not been at Corinth for several years; and in the interval Timothy had been with him, so that Timothy did not need at a later period to be told about that visit ( Ac 20:2 , 4 ). For all these reasons the imprisonment, during which he wrote Second Timothy, is shown to be his second imprisonment. Moreover, He 13:23 , 24 , represents the writer (who was probably Paul) as in Italy, and at liberty. So Clement of Rome [First Epistle to the Corinthians, 1.5], the disciple of Paul, explicitly states, "In the east and west, Paul as a preacher instructed the whole world (that is, the Roman empire) in righteousness, and having gone to the extremity of the west, and having borne witness before the rulers (of Rome), he so was removed from the world." This plainly implies that he fulfilled his design ( Ro 15:24-28 ) of a missionary journey into Spain. The canon of the New Testament, compiled about A.D. 170 (called Muratori's Canon), also mentions "the journey of Paul from Rome to Spain." See Routh [Sacred Fragments, vol. 4, p. 1-12].
His martyrdom is universally said to have occurred in Nero's reign [Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, 2.22; Jerome, On Illustrious Men]. Five years thus seem to have elapsed between the first imprisonment, A.D. 63 ( Ac 28:17-31 ), and his martyrdom, June A.D. 68, the last year of Nero's reign. He was probably arrested by the magistrates in Nicopolis ( Tit 3:12 ) in Epirus, in the winter, on a double charge, first, of being one of the Christians who had conspired, it was alleged by Nero's partisans, to set fire to Rome, A.D. 64; secondly, of introducing a novel and unlawful religion. His friends all left him, except Luke: Demas from "love of this present world": the others from various causes ( 2Ti 4:10 , 11 ). On the first charge he seems to have been acquitted. His liberation from his first imprisonment took place in A.D. 63, the year before the great fire at Rome, which Nero made the pretext for his persecution of the Christians. Every cruelty was heaped on them; some were crucified; some were arrayed in the skins of wild beasts and hunted to death by dogs; some were wrapped in pitch-robes and set on fire by night to illuminate the circus of the Vatican and gardens of Nero, while that monster mixed among the spectators in the garb of a charioteer. But now (A.D. 67 or 68) some years had elapsed since the first excitement which followed the fire. Hence, Paul, being a Roman citizen, was treated in his trial with a greater respect for the forms of the law, and hence was acquitted ( 2Ti 4:17 ) on the first charge of having instigated the Christians to their supposed acts of incendiarism before his last departure from Rome. Alexander the coppersmith seems to have been a witness against him ( 2Ti 4:14 ). Had he been condemned on the first charge, he would probably have been burnt alive, as the preceding martyrs were, for arson. His judge was the city Præfect. Clement of Rome specifies that his trial was (not before the emperor, but) "before the rulers." No advocate ventured to plead his cause, no patron appeared for him, such as under ordinary circumstances might have aided him; for instance, one of the powerful Æmilian house, under which his family possibly enjoyed clientship ( 2Ti 4:16 , 17 ), whence he may have taken his name Paul. The place of trial was, probably, one of the great basilicas in the Forum, two of which were called the Pauline Basilicas, from L. Æmilius Paulus, who had built one and restored the other. He was remanded for the second stage of his trial. He did not expect this to come on until the following "winter" ( 2Ti 4:21 ), whereas it took place about midsummer; if in Nero's reign, not later than June. In the interim Luke was his only constant companion; but one friend from Asia, Onesiphorus, had diligently sought him and visited him in prison, undeterred by the danger. Linus, too, the future bishop of Rome, Pudens, the son of a senator, and Claudia, his bride, perhaps the daughter of a British king (see on 2Ti 4:21 ), were among his visitors; and Tychicus, before he was sent by Paul to Ephesus ( 2Ti 4:12 ; perhaps bearing with him this Epistle).
Object of the epistle.-- He was anxious to see his disciple Timothy, before his death, and that Timothy should bring Mark with him ( 2Ti 1:4 ; 4:9 , 11, 21 ). But feeling how uncertain it was whether Timothy should arrive in time, he felt it necessary, also, to give him by letter a last warning as to the heresies, the germs of which were then being scattered in the Churches. Hence he writes a series of exhortations to faithfulness, and zeal for sound doctrine, and patience amidst trials: a charge which Timothy seems to have needed, if we are to judge from the apostle's earnestness in urging him to boldness in Christ's cause, as though Paul thought he saw in him some signs of constitutional timidity (2Ti 2:2-8; 4:1-5; 1Ti 5:22 , 23 ).
Paul's Death.-- Dioysius, bishop of Corinth (quoted in Eusebius [Ecclesiastical History, 2.25]) about A.D. 170, is the earliest authority for the tradition that Peter suffered martyrdom at Rome "about the same time" as Paul, after having labored for some time there. He calls Peter and Paul "the founders of the Corinthian and Roman Churches." The Roman presbyter, Caius (about A.D. 200), mentions the tradition that Peter suffered martyrdom in the Vatican. But (1) Peter's work was among the Jews ( Ga 2:9 ), whereas Rome was a Gentile Church ( Ro 1:13 . Moreover, (2) the First Epistle of Peter ( 1Pe 1:1 ; 5:13 ) represents him as laboring in Babylon in Mesopotamia. (3) The silence concerning Peter of Paul's Epistles written in Rome, negatives the tradition of his having founded, or labored long at Rome; though it is possible he may have endured martyrdom there. His martyrdom, certainly, was not, as Jerome says, "on the same day" with that of Paul, else Paul would have mentioned Peter's being at Rome in 2Ti 4:11 . The legend says that Peter, through fear, was fleeing from Rome at early dawn by the Appian Way, when he met our Lord, and falling at His feet, asked, Lord, whither goest thou? to which the Lord replied, I go again to be crucified. The disciple returned penitent and ashamed, and was martyred. The Church of Domine quo vadis, on the Appian Way, commemorates the supposed fact. Paul, according to Caius (quoted in Eusebius [Ecclesiastical History, 2.25]), suffered martyrdom on the Ostian Way. So also Jerome, who gives the date, the fourteenth year of Nero. It was common to send prisoners, whose death might attract too much notice at Rome, to some distance from the city, under a military escort, for execution; hence the soldier's sword, not the executioner's axe, was the instrument of his decapitation [Orosius, The Seven Books of History against the Pagans, 7.7]. Paul appears, from Php 1:12-30 , to have had his partisans even in the palace, and certainly must have exercised such an influence as would excite sympathy in his behalf, to avoid which the execution was ordered outside the city. Compare Tacitus [Histories, 4.11]. The Basilica of St. Paul, first built by Constantine, now stands outside Rome on the road to Ostia: before the Reformation it was under the protection of the kings of England, and the emblem of the order of the Garter is still to be seen among its decorations. The traditional spot of the martyrdom is the Tre Fontane, not far from the Basilica [Conybeare and Howson].
2Ti 1:1-18 . Address: Thankful Expression of Love and Desire to See Him: Remembrance of His Faith and That of His Mother and Grandmother. Exhortation to Stir Up the Gift of God in Him, and Not Shrink from Affliction, Enforced by the Consideration of the Freeness of God's Grace in Our Gospel Calling, and by the Apostle's Example. The Defection of Many: The Steadfastness of Onesiphorus.
1. This Epistle is the last testament and swan-like death song of Paul [Bengel].
according to the promise of life ... in Christ-- Paul's apostleship is in order to carry into effect this promise. Compare "according to the faith ... in hope of eternal life ... promise," &c. ( Tit 1:1 , 2 ). This "promise of life in Christ" (compare 2Ti 1:10 ; 2Ti 2:8 ) was needed to nerve Timothy to fortitude amidst trials, and to boldness in undertaking the journey to Rome, which would be attended with much risk ( 2Ti 1:8 ).
2. my dearly beloved son-- In 1Ti 1:2 , and Tit 1:4 , written at an earlier period than this Epistle, the expression used is in the Greek, "my genuine son." Alford sees in the change of expression an intimation of an altered tone as to Timothy, more of mere love, and less of confidence, as though Paul saw m him a want of firmness, whence arose the need of his stirring up afresh the faith and grace in Him ( 2Ti 1:6 ). But this seems to me not justified by the Greek word agapetos, which implies the attachment of reasoning and choice, on the ground of merit in the one "beloved," not of merely instinctive love. See Trench [Greek Synonyms of the New Testament].
3. I thank-- Greek, "I feel gratitude to God."
whom I serve from my forefathers-- whom I serve ( Ro 1:9 ) as did my forefathers. He does not mean to put on the same footing the Jewish and Christian service of God; but simply to assert his own conscientious service of God as he had received it from his progenitors (not Abraham, Isaac, &c., whom he calls "the fathers," not "progenitors" as the Greek is here; Ro 9:5 ). The memory of those who had gone before to whom he is about to be gathered, is now, on the eve of death, pleasant to him; hence also, he calls to mind the faith of the mother and grandmother of Timothy; as he walks in the faith of his forefathers ( Ac 23:1 ; 24:14 ; 26:6 , 7 ; 28:20 ), so Timothy should persevere firmly in the faith of his parent and grandparent. Not only Paul, but the Jews who reject Christ, forsake the faith of their forefathers, who looked for Christ; when they accept Him, the hearts of the children shall only be returning to the faith of their forefathers (Mal 4:6; Lu 1:17 ; Ro 11:23 , 24, 28). Probably Paul had, in his recent defense, dwelt on this topic, namely, that he was, in being a Christian, only following his hereditary faith.
that ... I have remembrance of thee-- "how unceasing I make my mention concerning thee" (compare Phm 4). The cause of Paul's feeling thankful is, not that he remembers Timothy unceasingly in his prayers, but for what Timothy is in faith ( 2Ti 1:5 ) and graces; compare Ro 1:8 , 9 , from which supply the elliptical sentence thus, "I thank God (for thee, for God is my witness) whom I serve ... that (or how) without ceasing I have remembrance (or make mention) of thee," &c.
night and day-- (See on 1Ti 5:5 ).
6. Wherefore-- Greek, "For which cause," namely, because thou hast inherited, didst once possess, and I trust ("am persuaded") still dost possess, such unfeigned faith [Alford].
stir up-- literally, "rekindle," "revive the spark of"; the opposite of "quench" or "extinguish" ( 1Th 5:19 ). Paul does not doubt the existence of real faith in Timothy, but he desires it to be put into active exercise. Timothy seems to have become somewhat remiss from being so long without Paul ( 2Ti 2:22 ).
gift of God-- the spiritual grace received for his ministerial office, either at his original ordination, or at his consecration to the particular office of superintending the Ephesian Church (see on 1Ti 4:14 ), imparting fearlessness, power, love, and a sound mind ( 2Ti 1:7 ).
by the putting on of my hands-- In 1Ti 4:14 , it is "with [not by] the laying on of the hands of the presbytery." The apostle was chief in the ordination, and to him "BY" is applied. The presbytery were his assistants; so "with," implying merely accompaniment, is said of them. Paul was the instrument in Timothy's ordination and reception of the grace then conferred; the presbyters were the concurrent participants in the act of ordination; so the Greek, "dia" and "meta." So in ordinations by a bishop in our days, he does the principal act; they join in laying on hands with him.
7. For, &c.-- implying that Timothy needed the exhortation "to stir up the gift of God in him," being constitutionally "timid": "For God did not give us (so the Greek, namely, at our ordination or consecration) the spirit of fear." The spirit which He gave us, was not the spirit of timidity (literally, "cowardice," which is weakness), but of "power" (exhibited in a fearless "testimony" for Christ, 2Ti 1:8 ). "Power is the invariable accompaniment of the gift of the Holy Ghost. Lu 24:49 ; Ac 1:8 ; compare Ac 6:6 , "full of faith and of the Holy Ghost," with 2Ti 1:8 , "full of faith and power." Fear is the result of "the spirit of bondage" ( Ro 8:15 ). Fear within exaggerates the causes of fear without. "The spirit of power" is the spirit of man dwelt in by the Spirit of God imparting power; this power "casteth out fear" from ourselves, and stimulates us to try to cast it out of others ( 1Jo 4:18 ).
love-- which moves the believer while "speaking the truth" with power, when giving his testimony for Christ ( 2Ti 1:8 ), at the same time to do so "in love" ( Ep 4:15 ).
a sound mind-- The Greek, is rather, "the bringing of men to a sound mind" [Wahl]. Bengel supports English Version, "a sound mind," or "sober-mindedness"; a duty to which a young man like Timothy especially needed to be exhorted ( 2Ti 2:22 ; 1Ti 4:12 ; Tit 2:4 , 6 ). So Paul urges him, in 2Ti 2:4 , to give up worldly entanglements, which as thorns ( Lu 8:14 ) choke the word. These three gifts are preferable to any miraculous powers whatever.
8. therefore-- seeing that God hath given us such a spirit, not that of fear.
Be not thou ... ashamed-- I agree with Ellicott, in opposition to Alford, that the Greek subjunctive here, with the negative, implies action completed at one time, not continued action, which the present imperative would express; thus implying that Timothy had not decidedly yet evinced such feeling of shame; though I think, Paul, amidst the desertion of others who once promised fair, and from being aware of Timothy's constitutional timidity (see on 2Ti 1:7 ), felt it necessary to stir him up and guard him against the possibility of unchristian dereliction of duty as to bold confession of Christ. Shame ( 2Ti 1:8 ) is the companion of fear ( 2Ti 1:7 ); if fear be overcome, false shame flees [Bengel]. Paul himself ( 2Ti 1:12 ), and Onesiphorus ( 2Ti 1:16 ), were instances of fearless profession removing false shame. He presents in contrast sad instances of fear and shame ( 2Ti 1:15 ).
of the testimony of our Lord-- of the testimony which thou art bound to give in the cause of our Lord; he says "our," to connect Timothy and himself together in the testimony which both should give for their common Lord. The testimony which Christ gave before Pilate ( 1Ti 6:12 , 13 ), is an incentive to the believer that he should, after His Lord's example, witness a good testimony or confession.
nor of me his prisoner-- The cause of God's servants is the cause of God Himself ( Ep 4:1 ). Timothy might easily be tempted to be ashamed of one in prison, especially as not only worldly shame, but great risk, attended any recognition of Paul the prisoner.
be thou partaker-- with me.
of the gospel-- rather, as Greek, "for the Gospel," that is, suffered for the Gospel ( 2Ti 2:3-5 ; Phm 13).
according to the power of God-- exhibited in having saved and called us ( 2Ti 1:9 ). God who has done the greater act of power (that is, saved us), will surely do the less (carry us safe through afflictions borne for the Gospel). "Think not that thou hast to bear these afflictions by thine own power; nay, it is by the power of God. It was a greater exercise of power than His making the heaven, His persuading the world to embrace salvation" [Chrysostom].
9. Who ... called us-- namely, God the Father ( Ga 1:6 ). The having "saved us" in His eternal purpose of "grace, given us in Christ before the world began," precedes his actual "calling" of us in due time with a call made effective to us by the Holy Spirit; therefore, "saved us" comes before "called us" ( Ro 8:28-30 ).
holy calling-- the actual call to a life of holiness. He 3:1 , "heavenly calling" [Tittmann, Greek Synonyms of the New Testament]; whereas we were sinners and enemies ( Ep 1:18 ; 4:1 ). The call comes wholly from God and claims us wholly for God. "Holy" implies the separation of believers from the rest of the world unto God.
not according to-- not having regard to our works in His election and calling of grace ( Ro 9:11 ; Ep 2:8 , 9 ).
his own purpose-- The origination of salvation was of His own purpose, flowing from His own goodness, not for works of ours coming first, but wholly because of His own gratuitous, electing love [Theodoret and Calvin].
grace ... given us-- in His everlasting purpose, regarded as the same as when actually accomplished in due time.
in Christ-- believers being regarded by God as IN Him, with whom the Father makes the covenant of salvation ( Ep 1:4 ; 3:11 ).
before the world began-- Greek, "before the times (periods) of ages"; the enduring ages of which no end is contemplated ( 1Co 2:7 ; Ep 3:11 ).
10. But ... now ... manifest-- in contrast to its concealment heretofore in the eternal purpose of God "before the world began" ( 2Ti 1:9 ; Col 1:16 ; Tit 1:2 , 3 ).
appearing-- the visible manifestation in the flesh.
abolished death-- Greek, "taken away the power from death" [Tittmann]. The Greek article before "death" implies that Christ abolished death, not only in some particular instance, but in its very essence, being, and idea, as well as in all its aspects and consequences ( Joh 11:26 ; Ro 8:2 , 38 ; 1Co 15:26 , 55 ; He 2:14 ). The carrying out of the abolition of death into full effect is to be at the resurrection ( Re 20:14 ). The death of the body meanwhile is but temporary, and is made no account of by Christ and the apostles.
brought ... to light-- making visible by the Gospel what was before hidden in God's purpose.
life-- of the Spirit, acting first on the soul here, about to act on the body also at the resurrection.
immortality-- Greek, "incorruptibility" of the new life, not merely of the risen body [Alford], ( Ro 8:11 ).
through-- by means of the Gospel, which brings to light the life and immortality purposed by God from eternity, but manifested now first to man by Christ, who in His own resurrection has given the pledge of His people's final triumph over death through Him. Before the Gospel revelation from God, man, by the light of nature, under the most favorable circumstances, had but a glimmering idea of the possibility of a future being of the soul, but not the faintest idea of the resurrection of the body ( Ac 17:18 , 32 ). If Christ were not "the life," the dead could never live; if He were not the resurrection, they could never rise; had He not the keys of hell and death ( Re 1:18 ), we could never break through the bars of death or gates of hell [Bishop Pearson].
11. Whereunto-- For the publication of which Gospel.
I am appointed-- Greek, "I was appointed."
preacher-- Greek, "herald."
teacher of the Gentiles-- ( 1Ti 2:7 ). He brings forward his own example in this verse and 2Ti 1:12 , as a pattern for Timothy, as a public "preacher," an "apostle," or missionary from place to place, and a "teacher" in private instructing His flock with patient perseverance.
12. For the which cause-- For the Gospel cause of which I was appointed a preacher ( 2Ti 1:10 , 11 ).
I also suffer-- besides my active work as a missionary. Ellicott translates, "I suffer even these things"; the sufferings attendant on my being a prisoner ( 2Ti 1:8 , 15 ).
I am not ashamed-- neither be thou ( 2Ti 1:8 ).
for-- Confidence as to the future drives away shame [Bengel].
I know-- though the world knows Him not ( Joh 10:14 ; 17:25 ).
whom-- I know what a faithful, promise-keeping God He is ( 2Ti 2:13 ). It is not, I know how I have believed, but, I know WHOM I have believed; a feeble faith may clasp a strong Saviour.
believed-- rather, "trusted"; carrying out the metaphor of a depositor depositing his pledge with one whom he trusts.
am persuaded-- ( Ro 8:38 ).
he is able-- in spite of so many foes around me.
that which I have committed unto him-- Greek, "my deposit"; the body, soul, and spirit, which I have deposited in God's safe keeping ( 1Th 5:23 ; 1Pe 4:19 ). So Christ Himself in dying ( Lu 23:46 ). "God deposits with us His word; we deposit with God our spirit" [Grotius]. There is one deposit (His revelation) committed by God to us, which we ought to keep ( 2Ti 1:13 , 14 ) and transmit to others ( 2Ti 2:2 ); there is another committed by God to us, which we should commit to His keeping, namely, ourselves and our heavenly portion.
that day-- the day of His appearing ( 2Ti 1:18 ; 2Ti 4:8 ).
Responsorial Psalm Psalm 123:1b-2ab, 2
1. ...Let this singer ascend; and let this man sing from the heart of each of you, and let each of you be this man, for when each of you saith this, since ye are all one in Christ, one man saith this; and saith not, "Unto Thee, O Lord, have" we "lift up" our "eyes;" but, "Unto Thee, O Lord, have I lift up mine eyes"
(ver. 1). Ye ought indeed to imagine that every one of you is speaking; but that One in an especial sense speaketh, who is also spread abroad over the whole world...
What maketh the heart of a Christian heavy? Because he is a pilgrim, and longeth for his country. If thy heart be heavy on this score, although thou hast been prosperous in the world, still thou dost groan: and if all things combine to render thee prosperous, and this world smile upon thee on every side, thou nevertheless groanest, because thou seest that thou art set in a pilgrimage; and feelest that thou hast indeed happiness in the eyes of fools, but not as yet after the promise of Christ: this thou seekest with groans, this thou seekest with longings, and by longing ascendest, and while thou ascendest dost sing the Song of Degrees.
2. ...Where then are the ladders? For we behold so great an interval between heaven and earth, there is so wide a separation, and so great a space of regions between: we wish to climb thither, we see no ladder; do we deceive ourselves, because we sing the Song of Degrees, that is, the Song of ascent? We ascend unto heaven, if we think of God, who hath made ascending steps in the heart. What is to ascend in heart? To advance towards God. As every man who faileth, doth not descend, but falleth: so every one who profiteth doth ascend: but if he so profit, as to avoid pride: if he so ascend as not to fall: but if while he profiteth he become proud, in ascending he again falleth. But that he may not be proud, what ought he to do? Let him lift up his eyes unto Him who dwelleth in heaven, let him not heed himself...
3. If, my brethren, we understand by heaven the firmament which we see with our bodily eyes, we shall indeed so err, as to imagine that we cannot ascend thither without ladders, or some scaling machines: but if we ascend spiritually, we ought to understand heaven spiritually: if the ascent be in affection, heaven is in righteousness. What is then the heaven of God? All holy souls, all righteous souls. For the Apostles also, although they were on earth in the flesh, were heaven; for the Lord, enthroned in them, traversed the whole world. He then dwelleth in heaven. How?...How long are they the temple according to faith? As long as Christ dwelleth in them through faith; as the Apostle saith, "That Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith." But they are already heaven in whom God already dwelleth visibly, who see Him face to face; all the holy Apostles, all the holy Virtues, Powers, Thrones, Lordships, that heavenly Jerusalem, wanderers from whence we groan, and for which we pray with longing; and there God dwelleth. Thither hath the Psalmist lifted up his faith, thither he riseth in affection, with longing hopes: and this very longing causeth the soul to purge off the filth of sins, and to be cleansed from every stain, that itself also may become heaven; because it hath lifted up its eyes unto Him who dwelleth in heaven. For if we have determined that that heaven which we see with our bodily eyes is the dwelling of God, the dwelling of God will pass away; for "heaven and earth will pass away." Then, before God created heaven and earth, where did He dwell? But some one saith: and before God made the Saints, where did He dwell? God dwelt in Himself, he dwelt with Himself, and God is with Himself. And when He deigneth to dwell in the Saints, the Saints are not the house of God in such wise, as that God should fall when it is withdrawn. For we dwell in a house in one way, in another way God dwelleth in the Saints. Thou dwellest in a house: if it be withdrawn, thou fallest: but God so dwelleth in the Saints, that if He should Himself depart, they fall...
4. What then followeth, since he hath said, "Unto Thee do I lift up mine eyes"?
(ver. 2). How hast thou lifted up thine eyes? "Behold, even as the eyes of servants look unto the hand of their masters, and as the eyes of a maiden unto the hand of her mistress: even so our eyes wait upon the Lord our God, until He have mercy upon us." We are both servants, and a handmaiden: He is both our Master and our Mistress. What do these words mean? What do these similitudes mean? It is not wonderful if we are servants, and He our Master; but it is wonderful if we are a maiden, and He our Mistress. But not even our being a maiden is wonderful; for we are the Church: nor is it wonderful that He is our Mistress; for He is the Power and the Wisdom of God...When therefore thou hearest Christ, lift up thine eyes to the hands of thy Master; when thou hearest the Power of God and the Wisdom of God, lift up thine eyes to the hands of thy Mistress; for thou art both servant and handmaiden; servant, for thou art a people; handmaiden, for thou art the Church. But this maiden hath found great dignity with God; she hath been made a wife. But until she come unto those spiritual embraces, where she may without apprehension enjoy Him whom she hath loved, and for whom she hath sighed in this tedious pilgrimage, she is betrothed: and hath received a mighty pledge, the blood of the Spouse for whom she sigheth without fear. Nor is it said unto her, Do not love; as it is sometimes said to any betrothed virgin, not as yet married: and is justly said, Do not love; when thou hast become a wife, then love: it is rightly said, because it is a precipitate and preposterous thing, and not a chaste desire, to love one whom she knoweth not whether she shall marry. For it may happen that one man may be betrothed to her, and another man marry her. But as there is no one else who can be preferred to Christ, let her love without apprehension: and before she is joined unto Him, let her love, and sigh from a distance and from her far pilgrimage...
5. "For we have been much filled with contempt"
Canticle. Hebrew adds, "of David." (Haydock) --- Syriac also attributes to him, though Zorobabel, &c., might recite it at their return. It may also refer to the captives groaning under oppression, (Calmet) and to every Christian, who must live in expectation of a better country. (St. Augustine) (Berthier, T. viii.)
Masters. Expecting liberty, or rather food; though it may also imply that they are ready to run at the first sign, which they observe with attention. Thus Menelaus had his eyes on Agamemnon. (Homer) (Calmet) --- As servants, and particularly handmaids, are very attentive, and hope to receive sustenance, so we ought to pray with all earnestness to God for what is necessary. (Worthington) --- All must come from Him. --- Until. Or "waiting for his having mercy on us." We shall not cease to look up to Him afterwards. (Berthier) --- "Take care not to turn thine eyes away from mine." (Terent. Adelph. ii. 1.)
1 Unto thee lift I up mine eyes, O thou that dwellest in the heavens. 2 Behold, as the eyes of servants look unto the hand of their masters, and as the eyes of a maiden unto the hand of her mistress; so our eyes wait upon the Lord our God, until that he have mercy upon us. 3 Have mercy upon us, O Lord , have mercy upon us: for we are exceedingly filled with contempt. 4 Our soul is exceedingly filled with the scorning of those that are at ease, and with the contempt of the proud.
We have here,
I. The solemn profession which God's people make of faith and hope in God, v. 1, 2 . Observe, 1. The title here given to God: O thou that dwellest in the heavens. Our Lord Jesus has taught us, in prayer, to have an eye to God as our Father in heaven; not that he is confined there, but there especially he manifests his glory, as the King in his court. Heaven is a place of prospect and a place of power; he that dwells there beholds thence all the calamities of his people and thence can send to save them. Sometimes God seems to have forsaken the earth, and the enemies of God's people ask, Where is now your God? But then they can say with comfort, Our God is in the heavens. O thou that sittest in the heavens (so some), sittest as Judge there; for the Lord has prepared his throne in the heavens, and to that throne injured innocency may appeal. 2. The regard here had to God. The psalmist himself lifted up his eyes to him. The eyes of a good man are ever towards the Lord, Ps. xxv. 15 . In every prayer we lift up our soul, the eye of our soul, to God, especially in trouble, which was the case here. The eyes of the people waited on the Lord, v. 2 . We find mercy coming towards a people when the eyes of man, as of all the tribes of Israel, are towards the Lord, Zech. ix. 1 . The eyes of the body are heaven-ward. Os homini sublime dedit—To man he gave an erect mien, to teach us which way to direct the eyes of the mind. Our eyes wait on the Lord, the eye of desire and prayer, the begging eye, and the eye of dependence, hope, and expectation, the longing eye. Our eyes must wait upon God as the Lord, and our God, until that he have mercy upon us. We desire mercy from him, we hope he will show us mercy, and we will continue our attendance on him till the mercy come. This is illustrated ( v. 2 ) by a similitude: Our eyes are to God as the eyes of a servant, and handmaid, to the hand of their master and mistress. The eyes of a servant are, (1.) To his master's directing hand, expecting that he will appoint him his work, and cut it out for him, and show him how he must do it. Lord, what wilt thou have me to do? (2.) To his supplying hand. Servants look to their master, or their mistress, for their portion of meat in due season, Prov. xxxi. 15 . And to God must we look for daily bread, for grace sufficient; from him we must receive it thankfully. (3.) To his assisting hand. If the servant cannot do his work himself, where must he look for help but to his master? And in the strength of the Lord God we must go forth and go on. (4.) To his protecting hand. If the servant meet with opposition in his work, if he be questioned for what he does, if he be wronged and injured, who should bear him out and right him, but his master that set him on work? The people of God, when they are persecuted, may appeal to their Master, We are thine; save us. (5.) To his correcting hand. If the servant has provoked his master to beat him, he does not call for help against his master, but looks at the hand that strikes him, till it shall say, "It is enough; I will not contend for ever." The people of God were now under his rebukes; and whither should they turn but to him that smote them? Isa. ix. 13 . To whom should they make supplication but to their Judge? They will not do as Hagar did, who ran away from her mistress when she put some hardships upon her ( Gen. xvi. 6 ), but they submit themselves to and humble themselves under God's mighty hand. (6.) To his rewarding hand. The servant expects his wages, his well-done, from his master. Hypocrites have their eye to the world's hand; thence they have their reward ( Matt. vi. 2 ); but true Christians have their eye to God as their rewarder.
II. The humble address which God's people present to him in their calamitous condition ( v. 3, 4 ), wherein, 1. They sue for mercy, not prescribing to God what he shall do for them, nor pleading any merit of their own why he should do it for them, but, Have mercy upon us, O Lord! have mercy upon us. We find little mercy with men; their tender mercies are cruel; there are cruel mockings. But this is our comfort, that with the Lord there is mercy and we need desire no more to relieve us, and make us easy, than the mercy of God. Whatever the troubles of the church are, God's mercy is a sovereign remedy. 2. They set forth their grievances: We are exceedingly filled with contempt. Reproach is the wound, the burden, they complain of. Observe, (1.) Who were reproached: "We, who have our eyes up to thee." Those who are owned of God are often despised and trampled on by the world. Some translate the words which we render, those that are at ease, and the proud, so as to signify the persons that are scorned and contemned. "Our soul is troubled to see how those that are at peace, and the excellent ones, are scorned and despised." The saints are a peaceable people and yet are abused ( Ps. xxxv. 20 ), the excellent ones of the earth and yet undervalued, Lam. iv. 1, 2 . (2.) Who did reproach them. Taking the words as we read them, they were the epicures who lived at ease, carnal sensual people, Job xii. 5 . The scoffers are such as walk after their own lusts and serve their own bellies, and the proud such as set God himself at defiance and had a high opinion of themselves; they trampled on God's people, thinking they magnified themselves by vilifying them. (3.) To what degree they were reproached: " We are filled, we are surfeited with it. Our soul is exceedingly filled with it. " The enemies thought they could never jeer them enough, nor say enough to make them despicable; and they could not but lay it to heart; it was a sword in their bones, Ps. xlii. 10 . Note, [1.] Scorning and contempt have been, and are, and are likely to be, the lot of God's people in this world. Ishmael mocked Isaac, which is called persecuting him; and so it is now, Gal. iv. 29 . [2.] In reference to the scorn and contempt of men it is matter of comfort that there is mercy with God, mercy to our good names when they are barbarously used. Hear, O our God! for we are despised.
1. (Compare Psa 121:1 ).
thou that dwellest-- literally, "sittest as enthroned" (compare Psa 2:4 ; 113:4, 5).
2. Deference, submission, and trust, are all expressed by the figure. In the East, servants in attending on their masters are almost wholly directed by signs, which require the closest observance of the hands of the latter. The servants of God should look (1) to His directing hand, to appoint them their work; (2) to His supplying hand ( Psa 104:28 ), to give them their portion in due season; (3) to His protecting hand, to right them when wronged; (4) to His correcting hand ( Is 9:13 ; 1Pe 5:6 ; compare Ge 16:6 ); ( 5 ) to His rewarding hand.
Gospel Mark 12:18-27
CHAPTER 12
1 The parable of the vineyard. 13 Touching the paying of tribute. 18 The Sadducees confuted. 35 A difficulty proposed to the scribes.
Ver. 1. Planted a vineyard. Gr. ε̉φύτευσεν, Vulg. pastinavit. The verb pastinare is especially used of vines. It means to dig the soil of the vineyard, and prepare it for planting vines, So the word repastinare means to dig up vines when they are sterile.
And dug a lake (Vulg.), a receptacle into which the must pressed from the grapes might flow. The Gr. is ύπολήνιον, i.e., beneath the winepress. For ληνός means winepress. Hence the Arabic translates, and dug a winepress in it. S. Matthew (xxi. 33) uses the same expression. For torcular, or winepress, means not only the actual press itself, but the vat or receptacle beneath the press in which the grape juice was received. This last was said to be dug, or, as in Isa_5:1, to be cut out.
Ver. 33. And to love one's neighbour as oneselg is a greater thing than all holocausts and sacrifices. Holocausts were sacrifices in which the whole victim was burnt and sacrificed to God by fire. This is what God says, "I will mercy [prefer] and not sacrifice, and the knowledge of God more than holocausts" (Hos_6:6). This young man tacitly assents to the saying of Christ, and condemns the scribes, who preferred sacrifices, which yielded profit to themselves, to mercy and the love of our neighbour. And this was why they bade children say to their parents, when they were in need, corban, i.e., oblation (see on Mat_15:6).
Ver. 34. Thou art not far from the kingdom of God. Thou art not far from the way of salvation, for the love of God and our neighbour is the pathway to heaven. Again it means, thou art not far from My Church, by which, militant here on earth, we go to the Church triumphant in heaven. "Still, as yet thou lackest faith to believe in Me as the Messiah, the Saviour of the world, and to obey My commands, so that thou mayest indeed become a Christian. And if thou wilt be perfect, leave all things and follow Me, as the Apostles have done." When, then, He says, thou art not far, "He shows," says Victor of Antioch, "that he was still at some distance, and that he ought to reach forward to that which was before, and seek diligently for the things that were yet wanting unto him."
Ver. 38. Who love to walk in long robes,stolis (Vulg.). The stole was an elegant garment, flowing down to the heels. Wherefore the Scribes wore it for the sake of ostentation.
Ver. 40. Who devour, Gr. οί κατεσθίοντες, i.e., who altogether consume and lick up the houses of widows, both by reason of the sumptuous feasts which they ask of them, as well as by the gifts and money which they avariciously extort from them under the pretext of offering prayers for them. "When, therefore," says Bede, "the hand is stretched out to the poor, it is wont to help prayer; but those men passed whole nights in prayer that they might take from the poor."
These shall receive greater judgment. A severer sentence of God, and a heavier condemnation shall press upon the Scribes in the day of judgment, because by a pretence of probity they are aiming at wrong-doing; and being clothed in the garments of God, they are fighting on the devil's side. "Simulated holiness," says S. Chrysostom, "is a double iniquity."
Ver. 41. How the people cast money: æs, brass (Vulg.), i.e., all sorts of money, whether brass, silver, or gold. For the first money was made of brass, hence all money was afterwards called brass, even when made of silver or gold.
Into the treasury; gazophylacium (Vulg.). For gaza is a Persian word, meaning riches; and φυλάττειν is to keep. This was a chest into which gifts were cast by the people, and kept for the service of the Temple, and for supporting the priests and the poor. Hence, also, the porch in which the chest was kept was called by the same name. Thus it is said in John viii. 20, "These words spake Jesus in the treasury (gazophylacio), teaching in the Temple." So Bede.
Ver. 42. A certain poor widow cast in two mites, which make a farthing. Not as if one mite made a farthing, as Euthymius understands, relying on Mat_5:26. But two mites were equivalent to one farthing, as is here clearly expressed. For a farthing was the fourth part of a little ass; and ten small asses made a denarius. A mite was half a farthing.
Ver. 43. This poor widow hath cast in more than all. For although per se, and other things being equal, the greatest and best alms and oblations is that which is most, yet, per accidens, when other things are not equal, the greater alms is that which is offered with the greater devotion of charity and religion. For God does not so much regard the gift as the disposition of the giver. Again, the greater gift is not that which is of the greater value considered in itself, as that which is the greater and more difficult in respect of the giver. This widow, therefore, in giving a farthing, gave more than all, because she gave all that she had, although it was necessary for her life. And she would have given more if she had had more. For she trusted in God, that He in return would be more liberal to her, and provide for her necessity, according to the saying, "Give God an egg, and receive a sheep." Others truly gave of their abounding superfluities, as Christ here says. As Titus of Bostra says on Luke xxi. 3, "With such magnanimity and devotion did she offer two mites, that is, all that she had, as if she counted her own life as nothing." S. Paul gives the a priori reason (2Co_8:12), "If there be a ready mind, it is accepted according to what a man hath, not according to that which he hath not." As Victor of Antioch says on this passage, "For God does not so much consider the greatness of the gifts, as weigh the greatness and alacrity of the mind." And Bede, "He weighs not the substance, but the conscience of the offerers."
For, as S. Thomas says, inasmuch as the widow gave according to her ability, therefore it was the greater affection of charity which was valued in her. S. Ambrose thought the same (lib. 2, Offic. c. 30), "The two mites of that widow surpassed the offerings of the rich, because she gave all she had; but they offered only a small portion of their abundance." Whence he infers, "The disposition therefore makes the offering poor or valuable, and sets their true price upon things." (Top)
Then come unto Him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection; and they asked Him, saying,19. "Master, Moses wrote unto us, ’If a man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.20. Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife, and dying left no seed.21. And the second took her, and died, neither left he any seed: and the third likewise.22. And the seven had her, and left no seed: last of all the woman died also.23. In the resurrection, therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.’ "24. And Jesus answering, said unto them, "Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the Scriptures, neither the power of God?25. For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven.26. And as touching the dead, that they rise: have ye not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spake unto him, saying, ’I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?’27. He is not the God of the dead, but the God of the living: ye therefore do greatly err."
After that our Lord has prudently escaped the crafty temptation of the Pharisees, it is shewn how He also confounds the Sadducees, who tempt Him. Wherefore it is said: "Then come unto Him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection."
A certain heretical sect of the Jews called Sadducees denied the resurrection, and said that there was neither angel nor spirit. These then coming to Jesus, craftily proposed to Him a certain tale, in order to shew that no resurrection should take place, or had taken place; and therefore there is added, "And they asked Him, saying, Master." And in this tale they lay down that seven men had married one woman, in order to make men draw back from belief in the resurrection.
And fitly do they frame such a fable in order to prove the madness of those who assert the resurrection of the body. Such a thing however might really have happened at some time or other among them.
But in a mystical sense: what can this woman, leaving no seed to seven brothers, and last of all dying, mean except the Jewish synagogue, deserted by the seven-fold Spirit, which filled those seven patriarchs, who did not leave to her the seed of Abraham, that is, Jesus Christ?
For although a Son was born to them, nevertheless He was given to us Gentiles. This woman was dead to Christ, nor shall she be joined in the resurrection to any patriarch of the seven; for by the number seven is meant the whole company of the faithful. Thus it is said contrariwise by Isaiah, "Seven women shall take hold of one man;" [ Isa 4:1 ] that is, the seven Churches, which the Lord loves, reproves, and chastises, adore Him with one faith.
"And Jesus answering, said unto them, Do ye not therefore err, not knowing the Scripture, neither the power of God?"
As if He had said, Ye understand not what sort of a resurrection the Scriptures announce; for ye believe that there will be a restoration of our bodies, such as they are now, but it shall not be so. Thus then ye know not the Scriptures; neither again do ye know the power of God; for ye consider it as a difficult thing, saying, How can the limbs, which have been scattered, be united together and joined to the soul? But this in respect to the Divine power is as nothing.
"For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven;" as if He had said, there will be a certain heavenly and angelic restoration to life, when there shall be no more decay, and we shall remain unchanged; and for this reason marriage shall cease. For marriage now exists on account of our decay, that we may be carried on by succession of our race, and not fail; but then we shall be as the Angels, who need no succession by marriage, and never come to an end.
We must here consider that the Latin custom does not answer to the Greek idiom. For properly different words are used for the marriage of men, and that of women; but here we may simply understand that, "marry," is meant of men, and "given in marriage" of women.
Thus then they do not understand the Scripture, in that in the resurrection, men shall be as the Angels of God, that is, no man there dies, no one is born, no infant is there, no old men.
In another way also they are deceived, not understanding the Scriptures; for if they had understood them, they should also have understood how by the Scriptures the resurrection of the dead may be proved.
Wherefore He adds, "And as touching the dead, that they rise, have ye not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spake unto him, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?"
But I say, "I am the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob."
As if He had said, "The God of the living," wherefore He adds, "He is not the God of the dead, but of the living;" for He did not say, I have been, but "I am," as if they had been present. But some one perhaps will say, that God spake this only of the soul of Abraham, not of his body; to which I answer, that Abraham implies both, that is, soul and body, so that He also is the God of the body, and the body lives with God, that is, in God’s ordinance.
Or else; because after proving that the soul remained after death, (for God could not be God of those who did not exist at all,) the resurrection of the body also might be inferred as a consequence, since it had done good and evil with the soul.
But when He says, "The God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob;" by naming God thrice, He implied the Trinity. But when He says, "He is not the God of the dead," by naming again the One God, He implies One Substance. But they live who make good the portion, which they had chosen; and they are dead, who have lost what they had made good. "Ye therefore do greatly err."
That is, because they contradicted the Scriptures, and derogated from the power of God.
The doctrine of the resurrection from the dead is clearly given in the book of Moses, where mention is made of the burning bush, from the midst of which God appeared to Moses: have you not read, I say, what God there said to him? As God is the God of the living, you must be in an egregious error in imagining, that such as die in the eyes of the world not to return thither any more, die in the same manner in the eyes of God, to live no more. (Bible de Vence)
18 Then come unto him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection; and they asked him, saying, 19 Master, Moses wrote unto us, If a man's brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother. 20 Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife, and dying left no seed. 21 And the second took her, and died, neither left he any seed: and the third likewise. 22 And the seven had her, and left no seed: last of all the woman died also. 23 In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife. 24 And Jesus answering said unto them, Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures, neither the power of God? 25 For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven. 26 And as touching the dead, that they rise: have ye not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spake unto him, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob? 27 He is not the God of the dead, but the God of the living: ye therefore do greatly err.
The Sadducees, who were the deists of that age, here attack our Lord Jesus, it should seem, not as the scribes, and Pharisees, and chief-priests, with any malicious design upon his person; they were not bigots and persecutors, but sceptics and infidels, and their design was upon his doctrine, to hinder the spreading of that: they denied that there was any resurrection, and world of spirits, any state of rewards and punishments on the other side of death: now those great and fundamental truths which they denied, Christ had made it his business to establish and prove, and had carried the notion of them much further that ever it was before carried; and therefore they set themselves to perplex his doctrine.
I. See here the method they take to entangle it; they quote the ancient law, by which, if a man died without issue, his brother was obliged to marry his widow, v. 19 . They suppose a case to happen that, according to that law, seven brothers were, successively, the husbands of one woman, v. 20 . Probably, these Sadducees, according to their wonted profaneness, intended hereby to ridicule that law, and so to bring the whole frame of the Mosaic institution into contempt, as absurd and inconvenient in the practice of it. Those who deny divine truths, commonly set themselves to disparage divine laws and ordinances. But this was only by the by; their design was to expose the doctrine of the resurrection; for they suppose that if there be a future state, it must be such a one as this, and then the doctrine, they think, is clogged either with this invincible absurdity, that a woman in that state must have seven husbands, or else with this insolvable difficulty, whose wife must she be. See with what subtlety these heretics undermine the truth; they do not deny it, nor say, There can be no resurrection; nay, they do not seem to doubt of it, nor say, If there be a resurrection, whose wife shall she be? as the devil to Christ, If thou be the Son of God. But, as though these beasts of the field were more subtle than the serpent himself, they pretend to own the truth, as if they were not Sadducees, no not they; who said that they denied the resurrection? They take it for granted that there is a resurrection, and would be thought to desire instruction concerning it, when really they are designing to give a fatal stab, and think that they shall do it. Note, It is the common artifice of heretics and Sadducees to perplex and entangle the truth, which they have not the impudence to deny.
II. See here the method Christ takes to clear and establish this truth, which they attempted to darken, and give a shock to. This was a matter of moment, and therefore Christ does not pass it over lightly, but enlarges upon it, that, if they should not be reclaimed, yet others might be confirmed.
1. He charges the Sadducees with error, and charges that upon their ignorance. They who banter the doctrine of the resurrection as some do in our age, would be thought the only knowing men, because the only free thinkers, when really they are the fools in Israel, and the most enslaved and, prejudiced thinkers in the world. Do ye not therefore err? Ye cannot but be sensible of it yourselves, and that the cause of your error is, (1.) Because ye do not know the scriptures. Not but that the Sadducees had read the scriptures, and perhaps were ready in them; yet they might be truly said not to know the scriptures, because they did not know the sense and meaning of them, but put false constructions upon them; or they did not receive the scriptures as the word of God, but set up their own corrupt reasonings in opposition to the scripture, and would believe nothing but what they could see. Note, A right knowledge of the scripture, as the fountain whence all revealed religion now flows, and the foundation on which it is built, is the best preservative against error. Keep the truth, the scripture-truth, and it shall keep thee. (2.) Because ye know not the power of God. They could not but know that God is almighty, but they would not apply that doctrine to this matter, but gave up the truth to the objections of the impossibility of it, which would all have been answered, if they had but stuck to the doctrine of God's omnipotence, to which nothing is impossible. This therefore which God hath spoken once, we are concerned to hear twice, to hear and believe, to hear and apply—that power belongs to God, Ps. lxii. 11 ; Rom. iv. 19-21 . The same power that made soul and body and preserved them while they were together, can preserve the body safe, and the soul active, when they are parted, and can unite them together again; for behold, the Lord's arm is not shortened. The power of God, seen in the return of the spring ( Ps. civ. 30 ), in the reviving of the corn ( John xii. 24 ), in the restoring of an abject people to their prosperity ( Ezek. xxxvii. 12-14 ), in the raising of so many to life, miraculously, both in the Old Testament and in the New, and especially in the resurrection of Christ ( Eph. i. 19, 20 ), are all earnests of our resurrection by the same power ( Phil. iii. 21 ); according to the mighty working whereby he is able to subdue all things to himself.
2. He sets aside all the force of their objection, by setting the doctrine of the future state in a true light ( v. 25 ); When they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage. It is a folly to ask, Whose wife shall she be of the seven? For the relation between husband and wife, though instituted in the earthly paradise, will not be known in the heavenly one. Turks and infidels expect sensual pleasures in their fools' paradise, but Christians know better things—that flesh and blood shall not inherit the kingdom of God ( 1 Cor. xv. 50 ); and expect better things—even a full satisfaction in God's love and likeness ( Ps. xvii. 15 ); they are as the angels of God in heaven, and we know that they have neither wives nor children. It is no wonder if we confound ourselves with endless absurdities, when we measure our ideas of the world of spirits by the affairs of this world of sense.
18. Then come unto him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection-- "neither angel nor spirit" ( Ac 23:7 ). They were the materialists of the day. See on Ac 23:6 .
and they asked him, saying-- as follows:
19-22. Master, Moses wrote unto us-- ( De 25:5 ).
If a man's brother die, and leave his wife behind him ... And the seven had her, and left no seed: last of all the woman died also.
23. In the resurrection therefore when they shall rise, &c.
24. Do ye not therefore err, because ye know not the scriptures-- regarding the future state.
neither the power of God?-- before which a thousand such difficulties vanish.
25. For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage-- "neither can they die any more" ( Lu 20:36 ). Marriage is ordained to perpetuate the human family; but as there will be no breaches by death in the future state, this ordinance will cease.
but are as the angels which are in heaven-- In Luke ( Lu 20:36 ) it is "equal unto the angels." But as the subject is death and resurrection, we are not warranted to extend the equality here taught beyond the one point--the immortality of their nature. A beautiful clause is added in Luke ( Lu 20:36 )--"and are the children of God"--not in respect of character, which is not here spoken of, but of nature--"being the children of the resurrection," as rising to an undecaying existence ( Ro 8:21 , 23 ), and so being the children of their Father's immortality ( 1Ti 6:16 ).
26. And as touching the dead, that they rise: have ye not read in the book of Moses-- "even Moses" ( Lu 20:37 ), whom they had just quoted for the purpose of entangling Him.
how in the bush God spake unto him-- either "at the bush," as the same expression is rendered in Lu 20:37 , that is, when he was there; or "in the [section of his history regarding the] bush." The structure of our verse suggests the latter sense, which is not unusual.
saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?-- ( Ex 3:6 ).
27. He is not the God of the dead, but the God of the living-- not "the God of dead but [the God] of living persons." The word in brackets is almost certainly an addition to the genuine text, and critical editors exclude it. "For all live unto Him" ( Lu 20:38 )--"in His view," or "in His estimation." This last statement--found only in Luke--though adding nothing to the argument, is an important additional illustration. It is true, indeed, that to God no human being is dead or ever will be, but all mankind sustain an abiding conscious relation to Him; but the "all" here means "those who shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world." These sustain a gracious covenant relation to God which cannot be dissolved. (Compare Ro 6:10 , 11 ). In this sense our Lord affirms that for Moses to call the Lord the "God" of His patriarchal servants, if at that moment they had no existence, would be unworthy of Him. He "would be ashamed to be called their God, if He had not prepared for them a city" ( He 11:16 ). It was concluded by some of the early Fathers, from our Lord's resting His proof of the Resurrection on such a passage as this, instead of quoting some much clearer testimonies of the Old Testament, that the Sadducees, to whom this was addressed, acknowledged the authority of no part of the Old Testament but the Pentateuch; and this opinion has held its ground even till now. But as there is no ground for it in the New Testament, so Josephus is silent upon it; merely saying that they rejected the Pharisaic traditions. It was because the Pentateuch was regarded by all classes as the fundamental source of the Hebrew religion, and all the succeeding books of the Old Testament but as developments of it, that our Lord would show that even there the doctrine of the Resurrection was taught. And all the rather does He select this passage, as being not a bare annunciation of the doctrine in question, but as expressive of that glorious truth out of which the Resurrection springs. "And when the multitude heard this" (says Mt 22:23 ), "they were astonished at His doctrine." "Then," adds Lu 20:39 , 40 , "certain of the scribes answering said, Master, thou hast well said"--enjoying His victory over the Sadducees. "And after that they durst not ask Him any [question at all]"--neither party could; both being for the time utterly foiled.
The Great Commandment ( Mr 12:28-34 ).
"But when the Pharisees had heard that He had put the Sadducees to silence, they were gathered together" ( Mt 22:34 ).
Three words in this charge are sharper in the original than the Douay can show, and the Haydock notes flag each one. Stir up the grace of God (v. 6) renders a Greek verb, anazopurein, that the note explains as a metaphor for fire blown up again — quasi sopitum ignem excitare, as if to rouse a fire that has gone drowsy. Grace here is not a stock but an ember. The spirit of fear God has not given (v. 7) is likewise not fear in general: the note prints the word as deilias, timidity, and adds the explicit correction that it is not phobou — what is excluded is "a cowardly fear, and want of courage," not reverence. And labour with the gospel (v. 8) translates sugkakopatheson, glossed mala ferto mecum; Witham allows the Latin's sense of labouring with Paul in preaching, but says that by the Greek it means "be partner with me in suffering." Timothy is being asked to share a prison, not a workload.
Witham is at his most careful on a phrase easy to slide past. Paul thanks the God whom I serve from my forefathers, with a pure conscience (v. 3) — and Witham refuses the flattering reading. Paul had indeed always served the one true God, as his forefathers had, and that was true even while he persecuted Christians; but that persecution he did not do with a pure conscience, "but with a false mistaken zeal," and Witham adds the sentence that closes the escape route: "his ignorance could not excuse him, after he might have known Christ." Sincerity is not the same as a clean conscience, and inculpable ignorance has a terminus. On v. 6 the notes then diverge over what sacrament is in view. Witham takes the imposition of Paul's hands to be Timothy's ordination as bishop; Denis the Carthusian leaves it open between confirmation and orders and draws a larger conclusion from the ambiguity — the verse "seems to shew that the imposition of hands is used in these two sacraments, as the essential matter," the instrumental cause of the grace conferred. Witham's ear for translation shows again at sobriety: he notes that the Protestant versions render sophronismou "a sound mind" here while rendering the same word "sobriety" in Acts xxvi. 25, 1 Timothy ii. 9, and Titus i. 8.
The most contested phrase is the last. That which I have committed unto him is depositum meum, paratheken mou, and Witham reports the common interpretation: what Paul has deposited in God's hands is the treasure of an eternal reward due in some measure to his apostolic labours, which God will repay at the last day. But Chrysostom declines to close the question, saying the deposit may be either what Paul committed to God's trust or what God committed to Paul — and the two readings pull in opposite directions, one making Paul the depositor and God the guarantor, the other making Paul the trustee who must not lose what he holds. The reading refuses to let either alternative become comfortable. If the deposit is Paul's, then the confidence in v. 12 is not self-confidence: I know whom I have believed, not what I have achieved. If it is God's, then the ember of v. 6 is somebody else's fire, lent out, and the cowardice named in v. 7 is not a temperament to be excused but a failure to blow on it.