✠ daily readings

jump to a date

readings are available from 2025-01-01 through 2027-12-31.

search

search by feast, season, or scripture reference.

type to search…

←
Lectionary 361 · Year II · Weekdays in Ordinary Time — Year II

Wednesday of the 10th week in Ordinary Time

→
USCCB ↗

First Reading · 1 Kings 18:20-39

20Achab sent to all the children of Israel, and gathered together the prophets unto mount Carmel.21And Elias coming to all the people, said: How long do you halt between two sides? If the Lord be God, follow him: but if Baal, then follow him. And the people did not answer him a word.22And Elias said again to the people: I only remain a prophet of the Lord: but the prophets of Baal are four hundred and fifty men.23Let two bullocks be given us, and let them choose one bullock for themselves, and cut it in pieces, and lay it upon wood, but put no fire under: and I will dress the other bullock, and lay it on wood, and put no fire under it.24Call ye on the names of your gods, and I will call on the name of my Lord: and the God that shall answer by fire, let him be God. And all the people answering, said: A very good proposal.25Then Elias said to the prophets of Baal: Choose you one bullock and dress it first, because you are many: and call on the names of your gods; but put no fire under.26And they took the bullock, which he gave them, and dressed it: and they called on the name of Baal from morning even until noon, saying: O Baal, hear us. But there was no voice, nor any that answered: and they leaped over the altar that they had made.27And when it was now noon, Elias jested at them, saying: Cry with a louder voice: for he is a god; and perhaps he is talking, or is in an inn, or on a journey; or perhaps he is asleep, and must be awaked.28So they cried with a loud voice, and cut themselves after their manner with knives and lancets, till they were all covered with blood.29And after midday was past, and while they were prophesying, the time was come of offering sacrifice, and there was no voice heard, nor did any one answer, nor regard them as they prayed.30Elias said to all the people: Come ye unto me. And the people coming near unto him, he repaired the altar of the Lord, that was broken down:31And he took twelve stones, according to the number of the tribes of the sons of Jacob to whom the word of the Lord came, saying: Israel shall be thy name.32And he built with the stones an altar to the name of the Lord: and he made a trench for water, of the breadth of two furrows, round about the altar.33And he laid the wood in order, and cut the bullock in pieces, and laid it upon the wood.34And he said: Fill four buckets with water, and pour it upon the burnt offering, and upon the wood. And again he said: Do the same the second time. And when they had done it the second time, he said: Do the same also the third time. And they did so the third time.35And the water run round about the altar, and the trench was filled with water.36And when it was now time to offer the holocaust, Elias, the prophet, came near and said: O Lord God of Abraham, and Isaac, and Israel, shew this day that thou art the God of Israel, and I thy servant, and that according to thy commandment I have done all these things.37Hear me, O Lord, hear me: that this people may learn that thou art the Lord God, and that thou hast turned their heart again.38Then the fire of the Lord fell, and consumed the holocaust, and the wood, and the stones, and the dust, and licked up the water that was in the trench.39And when all the people saw this, they fell on their faces, and they said: The Lord, he is God; the Lord, he is God.

commentary

Elias's opening question is not about which god is real but about posture: How long do you halt between two sides? (v. 21). Calmet takes "sides" concretely — the people were "sometimes adoring God; at other times the devil" — while Haydock finds them not so much choosing wrongly as refusing to choose, wishing "to unite the service of both, foolishly supposing that there might be many gods." Against that doubleness the chapter sets a run of stark singulars. At v. 22 the Hebrew repeats the pronoun "I," Haydock notes, "to make the contrast more striking": one visible prophet of the Lord against four hundred and fifty, though Abdias's hundred were alive and hidden and Jezabel's other four hundred never appeared at all. Even the trench is measured by a Hebrew agricultural unit, sathayim, "two measures of seed" (v. 32). And the Chaldean paraphrase strips the last dignity from v. 29's "while they were prophesying," rendering the word "acting like fools."

The commentators press hardest on whether such a contest is lawful. Worthington answers directly: "on such trying occasions, it is not tempting God to ask for a miracle," since God had given this proof by fire already at Genesis 15, Leviticus 9 and 2 Paralipomenon 7; and Elias "does not order them to invoke idols; but challenges them to prove their divinity, if they can." Salien grounds his nerve in something more specific than piety — Elias was "convinced that God would never suffer the devils to prevail on this occasion" — and Menochius supplies the corollary that makes the qualification necessary: the demons are not incapable of fire, only restrained, for "they might otherwise have brought down fire, as they will do in the days of Antichrist" (Apocalypse 13:13). Baal's silence is thus a verdict, not a vacancy. On the prophets' own frenzy Calmet and Haydock part company: Calmet reads their leaping about the altar as plain folly, the pagan circling Virgil describes (pingues spatiatur ad aras), while Haydock hears something bleaker — they acted "as if in jest, but really despairing of success." Their self-laceration Calmet sets among the rites of Bellona, Cybele and the Syrian goddess, forbidden at Deuteronomy 14:1.

The rebuilt altar answers that despair, and every part of it is deliberate. Menochius reads the twelve stones as Elias acting "in the name of all," so that, in Haydock's phrase, "all Israel might return with one heart"; Calmet forestalls the objection that the altar was irregular by insisting "the prophet did not follow his own spirit in erecting this altar." The four buckets poured three times serve a colder purpose — to "impede the natural activity of fire," Haydock says, and to leave no opening for the fraud a treatise circulating under Chrysostom's name attributes to pagan priests, who kindled altars from subterranean passages ita ut multi decepti ignem illum cœlestem esse existiment. The live form of the error is not Baal but Haydock's own contemporary target, those who "assert that many religions may be pleasing to heaven"; Worthington says the expostulation "ought to be made to those who are indifferent about religion." The fire, when it falls, does not merely light the wood: it takes the stones, the dust, and licks the trench dry.

· sources ·

The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.

First Reading 1 Kings 18:20-39

Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary · Public Domain
18:21

Sides: sometimes adoring God; at other times the devil. (Calmet) --- Such an expostulation ought to be made to those who are indifferent about religion. (Worthington) --- You cannot serve two masters. (Calmet) --- They wished to unite the service of both, foolishly supposing that there might be many gods; as some, at present assert that many religions may be pleasing to heaven. (Haydock) --- A word, not knowing the drift of his proposal. But, as they might perhaps rely that they considered Baal also as a god, Elias puts this to the test of a miracle; being convinced that God would never suffer the devils to prevail on this occasion. (Salien) --- They might otherwise have brought down fire, as they will do in the days of Antichrist, Apocalypse xiii. 13. (Menochius)

18:22

I. Hebrew repeats "I," to make the contrast more striking. Elias alone was present, in this assembly, as the prophet of the Lord. (Haydock) --- He knew that Abdias had preserved 100: but they were concealed. --- Men. The other 400 of Jezabel did not appear.

18:24

CHAPTER XVIII.

Call ye. He does not order them to invoke idols; but challenges them to prove their divinity, if they can. --- By fire. On such trying occasions, it is not tempting God to ask for a miracle. God had given this proof of fire repeatedly, Genesis xv. 17., Leviticus ix. 24., and 2 Paralipomenon vii. 1. He will restrain the devil's power, to confirm the truth, Mark xvi. 20. (Worthington)

18:26

That they. Hebrew, "which he (Achaz) had made;" (Calmet) or, "which was made." (Haydock) --- The altar of Elias was erected afterwards, ver. 30. The prophets of Baal acted in a foolish manner, (Calmet) as if in jest, but really despairing of success. (Haydock) --- The pagans were accustomed to dance around their altars: --- Pingues spatiatur ad aras. (Virgil, Æneid iv.) --- and some would translate, "near the altar." We might apply to these prophets, the verses of Horace:---

Dedit risusque jocosque,

Dum, flamma sine, thura liquescere limine sacro

Persuadere cupit: credat Judæus Apella

Non ego. (Sat. i. 5.)

18:27

Talking to some of his prophets, (Calmet) or in deep contemplation. (Montanus) --- An inn. Septuagint, "giving oracles;" or, "he is pursuing." (Pagnin)

18:28

Blood. Strange infatuation! which has nevertheless prevailed in many pagan mysteries and countries. Thus were Bellona, Cybele, the Syrian goddess, &c., honoured and appeased. (Calmet) --- God prohibits this fury, Deuteronomy xiv. 1. The devil always endeavours to destroy or to injure man. (Menochius)

"Ipsa bipenne suos cædit violenta lacertos,

Sanguineque effuso spargit inepta deam." (Tebullus)

18:29

Prophesying, "acting like fools;" (Chaldean) performing their superstitious rites, and singing the praises of their god, &c. (Calmet) --- Sacrifice, by Elias, who had assigned all the morning to Baal's prophets. Perhaps he waited till the time of the evening sacrifice, Exodus xxix. 38. (Menochius)

18:30

Down, by the false prophets, whose fury the people now repressed. (Tirinus) --- The altar might have been erected, under the judges, lawfully. (Calmet)

18:31

Twelve stones, (as [in] Exodus xxiv., &c.) intimating that he acted in the name of all; (Menochius) and in order that all Israel might return with one heart to the service of God. (Haydock) --- The prophet did not follow his own spirit in erecting this altar. (Calmet)

18:32

Furrows. Hebrew, "of two (sathayim) measures of seed." These furrows Elias filled with water, to impede the natural activity of fire, and to shew the miracle in a more striking light; (Haydock) as also to convince all that there was no deceit. An author quoted, under the name of St. Chrysostom, says that the pagans had sometimes subterraneous passages, by which they kindled the wood on the altar, as if by miracle, ita ut multi decepti ignem illum cœlestem esse existiment. (ap. Surium iv.)

18:34

Time. So that the wood was less disposed to catch fire. (Menochius)

18:37

Again. This effect he hoped for from the miracle.

18:38

Trench, as if it had been of an inflammable nature. Julian himself was forced to acknowledge this miracle. "This, says he, once happened under Moses, and, a long while after, again under Elias, the Thesbite."