✠ daily readings

jump to a date

readings are available from 2025-01-01 through 2027-12-31.

search

search by feast, season, or scripture reference.

type to search…

←
Lectionary 408 · Year I · Weekdays in Ordinary Time — Year I

Tuesday of the 18th week in Ordinary Time

→
USCCB ↗

First Reading · Numbers 12:1-13

1And Mary and Aaron spoke against Moses, because of his wife the Ethiopian,2And they said: Hath the Lord spoken by Moses only? Hath he not also spoken to us in like manner? And when the Lord heard this,3(For Moses was a man exceeding meek above all men that dwelt upon earth)4Immediately he spoke to him, and to Aaron and Mary: Come out you three only to the tabernacle of the covenant. And when they were come out,5The Lord came down in a pillar of the cloud, and stood in the entry of the tabernacle calling to Aaron and Mary. And when they were come,6He said to them: Hear my words: if there be among you a prophet of the Lord, I will appear to him in a vision, or I will speak to him in a dream.7But it is not so with my servant Moses who is most faithful in all my house:8For I speak to him mouth to mouth: and plainly, and not by riddles and figures doth he see the Lord. Why then were you not afraid to speak ill of my servant Moses?9And being angry with them he went away:10The cloud also that was over the tabernacle departed: and behold Mary appeared white as snow with a leprosy. And when Aaron had looked on her, and saw her all covered with leprosy,11He said to Moses: I beseech thee, my lord, lay not upon us this sin, which we have foolishly committed:12Let her not be as one dead, and as an abortive that is cast forth from the mother's womb. Lo, now one half of her flesh is consumed with the leprosy.13And Moses cried to the Lord, saying O God, I beseech thee heal her.

commentary

God's defence of Moses rests on a title. Moses is most faithful in all my house (v. 7), and Haydock, following Calmet, gives the Hebrew as neeman, steward or master of the palace. The same word marks Samuel and David, the Syrian general Naaman, and ambassadors; fidelity, Calmet says, often names an office as much as a virtue. Other prophets receive visions and dreams (v. 6). Moses is spoken to mouth to mouth, not by riddles and figures (v. 8), which Haydock compares to a man explaining his mind to his most intimate friend, though Calmet notes Moses still saw no bodily form of God's majesty. The quarrel begins somewhere else, with his wife the Ethiopian (v. 1). Challoner identifies her as Sephora of Madian, a land bordering Chus, so that the Ethiopia meant is Arabian, east of the Red Sea, and not African. Calmet sets aside Josephus's tale of an Ethiopian princess, and the Rabbinic readings, as without solid foundation.

The parenthesis of v. 3, Moses was a man exceeding meek above all men, draws the most comment. Challoner reasons that because the meekest of men would not contend for himself, the Holy Spirit obliged him to write the truth in his own defence, however much to his praise; Calmet adds that the same author records his own defects without reserve. Haydock argues that the peace of the nation was at stake, with the lawgiver slandered by his nearest kin and by those next to him in authority. Lapide allows that a later inspired writer may have inserted the verse. Haydock, citing Watson, answers Thomas Paine's use of it to call Moses vain and his books worthless: Paine praised his own refusal to return evil for evil while writing to cause all the mischief he could in church and state. On the punishment, Haydock judges Mary the more guilty, since she alone is struck. Calmet offers reasons for sparing Aaron: he may have sided with her out of complaisance, or God may have spared the priestly office public contempt and punished him in secret. Calmet adds that a fault's gravity is not always measured by its present punishment.

The chapter puts envy of a brother's gifts in its most respectable form, a question about who else God speaks to (v. 2). Haydock guesses that Sephora had claimed some pre-eminence from her husband's office and that Mary and Aaron answered by claiming the same honour. The text answers by placing Moses above them, and Moses answers by praying. Aaron, who a moment before spoke against him, now calls him my lord (v. 11), and Moses' only recorded words are O God, I beseech thee heal her (v. 13). The Chaldean renders Aaron's plea as "Permit not her to be separated from us, for she is our sister." The cloud lifts from the tabernacle door, and Mary stands white as snow with half her flesh consumed (vv. 10, 12).

· sources ·

The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.

First Reading Numbers 12:1-13

Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary · Public Domain
12:1

Ethiopian. Sephora, the wife of Moses, was of Madian, which bordered upon the land of Chus, or Ethiopia; and therefore she is called an Ethiopian: where note, that the Ethiopia here spoken of, is not that of Africa, but that of Arabia, (Challoner) on the east side of the Red Sea, Exodus ii. 15. Jealousy instigated Aaron and his sister on this occasion. (Calmet) --- Perhaps Sephora had claimed some pre-eminence on account of her husband's gorly, in being a mediator between God and his people, and therefore they pretend to the same honour, ver. 2. (Haydock) --- The Hebrew insinuates, that they laid hold on the pretext of Moses having married, or received again, a woman of a different nation contrary to the law which he had promulgated, "for it adds, he had married or retaken an Ethiopian woman." Others believe that he had put her away, and that Aaron and Mary stood up in her defence. "Mary and Aaron murmured against Moses, on account of the wife whom he had taken, who was a perfect beauty, because he had separated himself from his beautiful wife." (Onkelos) --- Some are of opinion, that this woman was Tarbis, the daughter of the king of Ethiopia, whom Moses espoused after he had terminated the wars between him and the Egyptians, before he retired to Madian. But this account of Josephus, (Antiquities ii. 5,) and the explication of Onkelos, and of the Rabbins, seem to be destitute of any solid foundation. (Calmet)

12:3

Exceeding meek. Moses being the meekest of men, would not contend for himself; therefore God inspired him to write here in his own defence: and the Holy Spirit, whose dictate he wrote, obliged him to declare the truth, though it was so much to his own praise. (Challoner) --- So he mentions his defects without reserve. (Calmet) --- There are occasions when a person may be not only authorized, but in a manner forced to declare what may be to his own praise. Moses was in such a situation. The peace of the whole nation was in danger, when false insinuations were thrown out against the lawgiver and king, by his own nearest relations, and by them who were next in authority to himself. Aaron, the high priest, countenanced at least the remarks of his sister, who seems to have been the most to blame, as she alone is punished with the leprosy. (Haydock) --- Some have suspected that this verse has been inserted by a later inspired writer. (Conrnelius a Lapide) --- But whether it was or not, there is no reason to infer with Thomas Paine, that Moses was either "a vain and arrogant coxcomb, and unworthy of credit, or that the books (attributed to him) are without authority." For if he did not write this verse, it does not follow that he wrote none of the Pentateuch; and if Paine scruples not to write of himself: "the man does not exist, that can say....I have in any case returned evil for evil:" and is not praising himself as a very meek man, when at the same time he is writing to cause all the mischief he can both in church and state, and thus during the heat of revolutionary madness, to involve thousands in ruin? (Watson) (Haydock)

12:5

Come to the door of the tabernacle, where Moses also was standing.

12:6

Vision. Other prophets were inspired in a more mysterious manner: Moses, though he saw not the majesty of God in any corporeal figure, was instructed by him in the most secret things with the utmost perspicuity, (Calmet) as if a man were explaining his sentiments to his most intimate friend, Exodus xxxiii. 19. (Haydock)

12:7

Faithful: Hebrew Neeman, steward or master of the palace. Such was Samuel, 1 Kings iii. 20; David, (Calmet) 1 Kings xxii. 14; Naaman, the general of Syria, 2 Kings v.; and Bacchides, 1 Machabees vii. (Haydock) --- Ambassadors had this title, (Proverbs xiii. 17,) and fidelity often denotes an office, 1 Paralipomenon ix. 22. Job (xii. 20,) speaks of the Namonim. (Calmet) --- But none among the Israelites was more justly entitled to this honour than Moses. He announced the word of God without any mixture of falsehood, and did not arrogate to himself more than his due, as Aaron seems to have done, ver. 2. (Haydock)

12:10

Departed from the door to its former place, (Calmet) as if in abhorrence of Mary's leprosy, (Hiscuni) and still more of the sin, which had brought upon her that punishment. (Calmet) --- Perhaps the cloud was raised higher in the air than usual, but did not proceed forward; (Menochius) otherwise the Israelites would have decamped. They remained at Haseroth till Mary was returned into the camp, ver. 15. (Haydock) --- Leprosy, of an incurable kind, like that of Gieze, 4 Kings v. 27. It covers the whole skin with a white scurf, Leviticus xiii. 10. Aaron is spared, either because he had sided with his sister only out of complaisance, without any formal malice against his brother; or because God, in consideration for his priestly character, would not render him contemptible in the eyes of the all people, intending to punish him in a more secret manner: for was are not always to judge of the grievousness of a fault, by its present punishment. Perhaps Aaron obtained pardon by his speedy repentance, ver. 11. (Calmet)

12:12

Dead; consumed by leprosy, or incapable of performing the duties of life. (Menochius) --- Hebrew, "an abortive, whose flesh is half consumed before he comes forth from his mother's womb." Septuagint, "he eateth half her flesh." "Permit not her to be separated from us, I beseech you, for she is our sister: pray, I beg, that her flesh may be healed," Chaldean.