✠ daily readings

jump to a date

readings are available from 2025-01-01 through 2027-12-31.

search

search by feast, season, or scripture reference.

type to search…

←
Lectionary 458 · Year II · Weekdays in Ordinary Time — Year II

Thursday of the 26th week in Ordinary Time

→
USCCB ↗

First Reading · Job 19:21-27

21Have pity on me, have pity on me, at least you my friends, because the hand of the Lord hath touched me.22Why do you persecute me as God, and glut yourselves with my flesh?23Who will grant me that my words may be written? who will grant me that they may be marked down in a book?24With an iron pen and in a plate of lead, or else be graven with an instrument in flint stone?25For I know that my Redeemer liveth, and in the last day I shall rise out of the earth.26And I shall be clothed again with my skin, and in my flesh I shall see my God.27Whom I myself shall see, and my eyes shall behold, and not another: this my hope is laid up in my bosom.

commentary

Job asks for his words to be cut with an iron pen and in a plate of lead, or else be graven with an instrument in flint stone (v. 24), and the Latin word behind instrument is disputed. Haydock reports that the received Vulgate reads celte, which Pineda explains as "a chisel", while the Benedictine editors, following several manuscripts, inserted certe, "surely". Calmet supports celte from a Dalmatian inscription recalling a time when there was "neither ink, nor paper, nor any parchments; but a flint stone was lettered with a mallet and a chisel", and Pineda adds that lead long remained a common writing surface. Calmet also identifies what Job wanted preserved, the sentence that follows, as proof of his "unshaken confidence in God" and as a refutation of friends who had accused him of despair and blasphemy. Tirinus remarks simply, "His desire has been granted."

The commentators read the confession of vv. 25-27 at two levels. Redeemer, Piscator says, may be understood of God without restricting it to the second Person, though Junius and Calmet see a more particular reference to Christ, "in whom he believed, as the Redeemer of all mankind". Chrysostom and Grotius take I shall rise out of the earth first of Job's recovery, "as an earnest and figure of the resurrection", and Calmet explains that a prophecy in Scripture often has "a double accomplishment", one near and one "more sublime and remote". The Hebrew raises a further question. Calmet renders it "he will raise himself one day upon the earth", like a conqueror or, for Amama, a wrestler standing over his opponent; Haydock faults Luther's "he will raise me up" as unfaithful to the Hebrew; Pineda defends the Vulgate by arguing that the verb can bear either sense, and that Job's rising follows from the Redeemer's, "So St. Paul argues; If Christ be risen, we also shall rise again." Calmet holds that Job's insistence on my flesh and my eyes shows he means more than restored favour and health. Gregory, as legate at Constantinople, used this text to persuade the patriarch Eutychius that risen bodies "will be palpable, and not aerial only". Jerome goes furthest, "No one since Christ has spoken so plainly of the resurrection, as this man did before the coming of the Messias."

The passage answers two diminished hopes. One shrinks the promise to recovery in this life, which the commentators allow as a first fulfilment and refuse as the whole. The other dissolves the resurrection into something airy, which Gregory resisted and Worthington answers, "We shall rise the same in substance." Calmet glosses whom I myself shall see as seeing God "for myself", and contrasts the reprobate, who will see their judge "to their eternal confusion". Job made his claim while his friends were still accusing him, and he wanted it cut in flint with a chisel, where it would outlast them.

· sources ·

The complete public-domain commentary this reading's note draws from, unabridged. Every claim in the note traces to a passage here.

First Reading Job 19:21-27

Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary · Public Domain
19:22

Flesh? acting with the like inhumanity towards me. Am I not then sufficiently tormented in you opinion, that you insult over my distress? (Calmet)

19:24

In a. Hebrew, "lead, in the rock for ever." (Protestants) Septuagint have, "for ever," after book, (ver. 23) and subjoins, "with a writing instrument of iron and (or) lead, or be engraven on the rocks for a memorial." Grabe insinuates that before there was only, "and on lead, or be engraven on the rocks." (Haydock) --- Instrument, (celte) means "a chisel," (Haydock) like cœlum from cœlo: " I engrave." (Pineda) --- St. Jerome, (ad Pam.) and the late editor of his works, retain this word, as the older editions of St. Gregory did; (Calmet) though certe, "surely," has been inserted instead, from several manuscripts by the Benedictines. (Haydock) --- Ancient manuscripts and Latin Bibles have more generally the latter word. But the received editions are supported by many manuscripts (Calmet) and the Septuagint Greek: eggluthenai, expresses as much. Celtis est, Greek:gluthaion. (Amama). (Casaub. in Atheneus vii. 20. p. 556.) --- An inscription, in Dalmatia, has the same sense: Neque hic atramentum vel papyrus aut membrana ulla adhuc; sed malleolo et celte literatus silex. "Here as yet was neither ink, nor paper, nor any parchments; but a flint stone was lettered with a mallet and a chisel.." The former modes of writing were not, in effect, invented by the days of Job. (Calmet) --- But it was long very usual to make use of lead. (Pineda) --- What he desired to have written in such durable characters, (Haydock) was the following sentence, in proof of his unshaken confidence in God, and as a refutation of his friends, who accused him of despair and blasphemy, (Calmet) as also the whole history of his conflict. His desire has been granted. (Tirinus)

19:25

Redeemer may be understood of the Deity, without confining it to the second Person; (Isaias xli. 14., and lxix. 7.; Piscator) though it may have a more peculiar reference to Christ: (Junius; Haydock) in whom he believed, as the Redeemer of all mankind. (Calmet) --- Earth. Yea, ere long I shall be restored to health, (St. Chrysostom; Grotius) as an earnest and figure of the resurrection. Nothing is more common, in Scripture, than for the same prophecy to have a double accomplishment; one soon after it is made public, and another more sublime and remote. Job seemed to have no expectation of surviving his present misery, (ver. 7., and chap. vii. 7., and xxiv. 15.) unless God now revealed it to him, as a figure of his future resurrection, founded on the hope of our Saviour's, which he expresses in much clearer terms. Hebrew, "I know that my Redeemer is living, and that he will raise himself one day upon the earth," (Calmet) like a conqueror, (Haydock) or wrestler, having overthrown his antagonist: (Amama) or, "he will stand the last upon the earth, or dust," (Piscator) ascending his throne, to judge all. (Deodat.) --- Yet Luther translates, "and one day he will raise me up from the earth;" which is not conformable to the Hebrew. Others explain, "he....will place (26) this, my skin, after they (worms) shall have ruined it." (Pagnin; Montanus) --- But Amama suspects that the latter is not in earnest. Pineda defends the Vulgate and observes that yakum (Haydock) may signify, "will raise" himself, or "me;" the latter being at least a consequence of the former, if St. Jerome did not read it me in his copy. So St. Paul argues; If Christ be risen, we also shall rise again. Septuagint, "For I know that he is eternal, who will set me free," (Haydock) by death, (Calmet; or redemption; Greek: ekluain) "upon the earth."

19:26

And I. Septuagint, "But he will raise up my body or skin, which has sustained these things. This now has been accomplished for me by the Lord; (27) which I know within myself, which my eyes have seen, and not another. For all things are accomplished in my bosom." I am as fully convinced of this glorious event, (Haydock) as if it were past. (Calmet) --- Hebrew, "and though, after my skin, worms destroy this body, yet in my flesh shall I see God." (Protestants, or in the margin, "After I shall awake, though this body be destroyed, yet out of," &c. Various other interpretations are given. (Haydock) --- But we had as well adhere to the Septuagint, Vulgate, &c. (Du Hamel) --- God. Sixtus V and some other editions, add "Saviour." (Calmet) --- Job would see the Messias by the eyes of his prosperity. (St. Augustine or Faustus, ser. 234. t. v. App.) (Sanctius) --- He hoped also to see God face to face in glory (Calmet) though not by means of his corporeal eyes, (Haydock) and to be restored to favour, so that God would no longer turn his back on him, chap. xlii. 5. St. Gregory, when legate at Constantinople, convinced the patriarch Eutychius, by this text, that after the resurrection, our bodies will be palpable, and not aerial only. (Calmet) --- It contains an express profession of Job's faith, on this head. We shall rise the same in substance. (Worthington)

19:27

Myself. Hebrew, "for myself," and for my comfort; not like the reprobate, who shall see their judge to their eternal confusion. Job insists so much on this point, that he shews he in not speaking merely of the divine favour being restored to him, in the re-establishment of his health and affairs, but that he raises his mind to something more solid and desirable, of which the former was only a faint representation. (Calmet) --- "No one since Christ has spoken so plainly of the resurrection, as this man did before the coming of the Messias." (St. Jerome, ad Pam.) --- This. Hebrew, "though my reins be consumed within me;" (Protestants; Haydock) or, "my reins (desires and tender affections) are completed in my bosom." (Calmet)